In your opinion who is the best full back at the club.Once you have selected one give him a rating out of 10.Not in relation as a Celtic player but as an overall player.
To help with player ratings. 1 being Biggins Standard and 10 being Messi.<!-- / message --><!-- edit note -->
Discuss Best FB in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.
Page 1 of 2
-
Last edited by a moderator: Feb 22, 2008
-
Hard to say ellboy at present havent seen enough of caddis hinkel or doumbe the others well seen enough of them
-
What i would say is the glimpses i have seen of the ones i mentioned they all have potential probaly go for hinkel the now cause he came with areputation
-
I hope Hinkel prove himself to be the best FB at the club and it is dificult to rate him so early. However from hat I have seen uptil now he is no better than what we have already got.
For me Doumbe is the best Full back we curently have on the books but IMO as an overall player I rate him a 5.
SO
DOUMBE 5 -
mk.celt1888
- Joined:
- Nov 22, 2006
- Messages:
- 284
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- kildare ireland
- Fav Celtic Player:
- wee jimmy
hinkel hopefully will turn out to be a class full back hes got experience and can be savage for us
-
Ellboy can you be more specific about the number rating?10 is Messi/Ronaldo calibre?
Anyway Hinkel for me based purely on his past career. -
Yes 10 being Messi calibre and 1 being biggins. -
Alright.Hinkel-7
-
Rosario FC
- Joined:
- Jul 27, 2005
- Messages:
- 5,642
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Danny McGrain, Henrik Larsson
- Fav Celtic Song:
- YNWA, The Celtic Song
Hinkel for me.....hard to score on evidence seen so far, but 7/10 for reputation/potential.
-
None o' them. We need new ones!
-
Hinkel is going purely on reputation. His defending so far has been very dubious. I am hoping he doesnt turn out to be a wingback who doesnt really like playing as a 4-4-2 FB. The Germans tend to play a back three (one is a sweeper) with wingbacks. I hope I am wrong but I have worries about Hinkel in a 4-4-2. Not that worried as we have some good options coming back now like Doumbe, Wilson and Caddis but I hope its not a waste of money. Here is a prediction: Hinkel will end up playing wide right in the midfield at some point. You heard it here first...
-
celticmad117
- Joined:
- Jan 14, 2007
- Messages:
- 5,041
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- Dublin
- Fav Celtic Player:
- The holy goalie, arthur boruc
hinkel so far, with doumbe 2nd
-
Naylor on everything i've seen so far, but i like the look of Hinkel i reckon post regaining of match fitness he'll be superb for us.
-
i would usually think of the best player in this poll,, but i cant,imthinking whos best of a shower of underachievers,,and i cant as if ure bad your bad
-
hinkels a german international with a good pedigree and i know thats means nothing till he proves himself at parkhead, but the other players we have are not the same quality. caldwell was a championship player down south as was naylor, i'm not sure if doumbe deserved a contract despite the cup final, wilson is good when fit and caddis is just starting. hinkel may be a bit too attacking at times but thats because he was a wing back in germany and is still getting used to playing in a back four but when he does i think he'll be excellent
-
Colin McRae
- Joined:
- Jan 19, 2007
- Messages:
- 9,148
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- Scotland
- Fav Celtic Player:
- henke
- Fav Celtic Song:
- YNWA
easy ones to go for is hinkel even though he's had a good game aganist stirling a poor game the week after and hearts show'd he wasn't up to pace
-
there's not much competition really, thought hinkel was pretty bad against hearts but he needs time to settle. hopefully he's settled in time for the old firm game
-
-
-
Got to say Naylor to be honest, yes he went through a bit of a rough patch late last season/early this season, and in Europe he's been found out at times, albeit by some excellent wingers. But at the end of the day, he has created some really important goals for us and on his game he is unstoppable, in Scotland at least.
Don't really know how people can say Hinkel, what has he done so far apart from scoring against the scumbos? And don't say your going by his previous reputation, unless of course you have seen him playing on a fairly regular basis. -
Because he has the biggest reputation
Page 1 of 2