Best FB

So did Gravesen when he came

 

It seems that Hinkel will win this pole.However he has only played 2 games.IMO the voting on Hinkel is being done more so in hope than with actual evidence of him being a good player.Yes he has 17 caps for Germany but we have to remember the germans were poor defensively and were looking to build a new defence when Hinkel won his caps.

He may turn out to be a fine Full back for us and I realy hope he does.

However it is pretty sad that after 3 years we dont have a clear Full back that everyone can honestly put their hands up and say he is outstanding and is the best and we vote for someone who has yet to play regulary for the Hoops .

 

Doumbe has to have played about 10 games or so, thats who i picked on performances for us, hinkle may prove to be the best over time if he lives up to the billing.
Who said Wilson, do we have rugby fans on this forum?

 

Just checked it hammer, your right 7 games in total, still enough for me to prefer him.

 

I voted for Doumbe as he has not realy put a foot wrong. However I only rated him a 5 as 6 or 7 games dont make you a player. However again for me he is not good enough to be a regular starter. This poll is realy depressing as they are all realy as bad as each other.

I can understand why Hinkel is getting the votes as we are hoping he proves to be a hit rather than rating him as a known quality Full Back.

 

Its got to be Naylor!!!!!!Hinkel hasnt played enough;and the RB slot seems to be jinxed.We dont have any other LB,so its Naylor,6/10.

 

Obviously we need to see more of Hinckel to see how well he will fit in at Celtic but for right now I give Hinckel a 7 and see him as our top full back.

 

After watching his disgraceful performance the other night gary, i'd say he's only good enough as a back up.