Was thinking about how good Nygren could be for us and whether Engels will kick on and it made me think of other attack minded midfielders we've had in the past 10 years and who was the best one.
I'm not including players who are still here but have only been here a year like Engels, McCowan etc. Or McGregor/Broony who became more defensive players over time.
Rank these from 1-9:
Stefan Johansen
Tom Rogic
Stuart Armstrong
Olivier Ntcham
Ryan Christie
David Turnbull
Aaron Mooy
Matt O'Riley
Reo Hatate
I find them very hard to rank tbh. Could be nostalgia bias, but a certain wizard would top my list.
Discuss Rate our 8's (or 10s) in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.
Page 1 of 2
-
Ryanm1984 likes this.
-
-
Officer Doofy Come to me, human man Gold Member
Feel like I need to work from the bottom up here.
1. Matt O'Riley
2. Tom Rogic
3. Reo Hatate
4. Ryan Christie
5. Aaron Mooy
6. Stuart Armstrong
7. Olivier Ntcham
8. Stefan Johansen
9. David Turnbullmayo, Mr Shelby, Zander and 1 other person like this. -
Difficult bcoz on form some where very good but a lot of them were inconsistent or had poor dips in form. Hatate can have that from one half to the next so iv done it with them all at their best
Rogic
O'Riley
Hatate
Armstrong
Mooy
Ntcham
Christie
Johansson
TurnbullZander and TheHappyLoss like this. -
I think my top 3 is the same with a slightly different order. Interesting you have Christie above Armstrong, I dont necessarily think it's wrong just think it'll be controversial
-
Officer Doofy Come to me, human man Gold Member
Think both of them had ups and downs and neither were perfect. Just think Christie was more of a goal threat and scored more in Europe.
Mooy would have been higher if he was here longer.Zander likes this. -
Probably a 9
:fear: -
Random Review
- Joined:
- Aug 31, 2012
- Messages:
- 24,480
- Likes Received:
- 10,788
- Location:
- Indonesia
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Jinky (ever) Lubo (modern era), KT (current)
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Fields of Athenry
In terms of who was the best player for us, judged over their time at Celtic as a whole, I'd go with this:
1. Tom Rogic
2. Reo Hatate
3. Matt O'Riley
4. Olivier Ntcham
5. Aaron Mooy
6. Stuart Armstrong
7. Stefan Johansen
8. Ryan Christie
9. David Turnbull
In terms of who was the best on the rare occasions when he could be bothered, I'd put Ntcham first and shuffle Rogic, Reo and MOR down one. -
1. Matt O'Riley
2. Tom Rogic
3. Reo Hatate
4. Aaron Mooy
5. Stuart Armstrong
6. Ryan Christie
7. Stefan Johansen
8. Olivier Ntcham
9. David Turnbull
Couldn't really stand Ntcham if I'm honest. He's got second last here but actually if I was picking a team to go out and win a game tomorrow he'd be the last player I'd wantSkelleto likes this. -
My list
1. Rogic
2. O'Riley
3. Hatate
4. Armstrong
5. Christie
6. Mooy
7. Ntcham
8. Johansen
9. Turnbull
I loved Rogic. Was tempted to put Hatate 2nd but MOR shades him in terms of output and consistency -
CookieMonster Geez yer cookies Gold Member
Definitely some nostalgia bias, O’Reilly just as inconsistent as Hatate but both equally as good. Rogic could be absolute magic or miles off it as well but they are top 3 by quite a distance.
Armstrong played a massive part for us for a few seasons but always struggled in Europe, Christie similar. Mooy was just too old but showed his quality after a rusty start. Johansen was an athlete and worked well with Broony but just lacked the quality. Turnbull added a lot of goals & assists but so * slow and finally Ntcham was just a moody *, could of been up near the top but his attitude was stinking.
Hatate
O’Reilly
Rogic
Armstrong
Christie
Mooy
Johansen
Turnbull
Ntcham -
Random Review
- Joined:
- Aug 31, 2012
- Messages:
- 24,480
- Likes Received:
- 10,788
- Location:
- Indonesia
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Jinky (ever) Lubo (modern era), KT (current)
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Fields of Athenry
Why do you have Turnbull ahead of Ntcham? Genuine question no offence intended. -
CookieMonster Geez yer cookies Gold Member
As I say at the end Ntcham’s attitude was * poor, if he actually played to his ability he’d be top 5. At least Turnbull always gave his all.Random Review likes this. -
Mr Shelby Moderator Moderator Gold Member
- Joined:
- Jan 7, 2012
- Messages:
- 56,721
- Likes Received:
- 47,025
- Location:
- West Lothian
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Larsson. Forever and always.
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Symphony
Ntcham gave me my best moment in a stadium supporting celtic in Rome. So always a bit bias with him.
Still think he had potential that we never fully witnessed.neilly1987, CookieMonster, Rydo1888* and 1 other person like this. -
Random Review
- Joined:
- Aug 31, 2012
- Messages:
- 24,480
- Likes Received:
- 10,788
- Location:
- Indonesia
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Jinky (ever) Lubo (modern era), KT (current)
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Fields of Athenry
-
Stefan Johansen 6
Tom Rogic 1
Stuart Armstrong 5
Olivier Ntcham 8
Ryan Christie 7
David Turnbull 9
Aaron Mooy 4
Matt O'Riley 2
Reo Hatate 3RalstonFanClubPresident likes this. -
Rogic apparently said he couldn't be bothered with football or to some effect and still done what he done , ntcham was just a lazy * with abundance of skill , johansen was class in spells and would've suited a better era , reo is top class but inconsistent, mooy was top drawer but again career coming to an end , strongleg had fine hair , Christie hit the roof of the stadium but other than that was decent and turnbull lacked turning on the baw.
-
Just put the names in order you *. :giggle1:neilly1987, Skelleto, King Kwon and 1 other person like this.
-
Taz Blind Justice Gold Member News Writer
- Joined:
- Sep 3, 2009
- Messages:
- 29,509
- Likes Received:
- 15,684
- Location:
- ...In Exile
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Paul McStay
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Celtic Symphony
Rating our 8's... That's tough. In fact, I would argue that Celtic's number 8 is perhaps even more overall important/influential/significant/symbolic than those that have worn the No. 7 jersey. Yes, Jinky and Henrik wore the 7, but there have been a lot of pretty ordinary footballers aside from those.
But the 8 is a different story. From the first Celt to wear the 8 in 1960, Willie Fernie (when Celtic started to wear numbers), followed by a notable lineage including John 'Yogi' Hughes and Willie Wallace, through Davie Hay and Bobby Murdoch to Johnny Doyle, before Paul McStay wore it for nearly his entire career, ahead of Craig Burley when the Bhoys 'Stopped the 10'. Since the turn of the millenium, there have been just the 3 and all 3 have undoubtedly left thier mark - Alan Thompson, Scott Brown and Kyogo Furuhashi.
Seriously, it reads like a who's who of Celtic over the past 65-odd years.Creativecelt and Random Review like this. -
O’Riley
Rogic
Christie
Mooy
Hatate
Johansen
Armstrong
Ntcham
Turnbull
Page 1 of 2