Player Ratings
Let me just say first of all even when it looks over, it's never over, never been to an old firm we haven't lost and it continues!!!! :icon_mrgreen::icon_mrgreen::icon_mrgreen:
Anyway player ratings:
Boruc: 6 - Nothing to do but pick the ball out
Hinkel 7 - Pushed on well, solid at the back
Caldwell 8 - Great night for Gaz minus the red
Mick 7 - Solid
Naylor 6 - Did well, injured subbed
Hartley 6 - Neat and tidy, did well for recovering from an injury
Robson 8 - Tenacious, fierce, everything you want in a midfielder
Naka 8 - 8 for the goal alone, incredible, should've had 2 if it wasn't for ugly betty
McGeady 7 - Not his game but plugged away as always and had moments
McDonald 6 - Should've scored the pen, made up for it with the assist
Jan 8 - Goal alone and did his fair share, don't know why he's always penalised though
Subs
Wilson 7 - Did really well and seems more suited to LB than right, deserves a run
Samaras 7 - Caused trouble and confusion
To sum up....MON THE * HOOPS!!!!!!!!!!!!! :50:
Discuss CELTIC v RANGERS PLAYER RATINGS in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.
Page 1 of 2
-
Ricardinho
- Joined:
- Sep 11, 2006
- Messages:
- 11,735
- Likes Received:
- 3
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Henrik Larsson
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Willie Maley
-
Boruc...6
Hinkel...7
Naylor...7 Wilson...7
Caldwell...8
McManus...7
Hartley...7
Robson...8
Nakamura...8
McGeady...8
JVOH...8
McDonald...6 -
Raz
- Joined:
- Jan 7, 2008
- Messages:
- 2,906
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- Helensburgh
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Hooper
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Just Can't Get Enough!
Agree'd m8.
Why the * does big jan always get penalised? -
Ricardinho
- Joined:
- Sep 11, 2006
- Messages:
- 11,735
- Likes Received:
- 3
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Henrik Larsson
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Willie Maley
Oh and I thought I'd throw something else out there to tell you how magic my day has been, told the lady in the stadium I wanted a £5 on Celtic 3-1, she misheard and gave me a £5, 2-1, when I got to my seat I was * off but I was loving it at the end
-
Boruc - 7
Hinkel - 7
Caldwell - 8
McManus - 7
Naylor - 7
Nakamura - 8
Robson - 8
Hartley - 8
McGeady - 6
Jan - 8
Skippy - 7 -
Hinkel 7
Caldwell 8
Mick 7
Naylor 6
Hartley 6
Robson 8
Naka 8
McGeady 7
McDonald 5
Jan 8
Subs
Wilson 6
Samaras 7 -
-
The Doctor
- Joined:
- Mar 12, 2006
- Messages:
- 16,028
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- Running with the shadows of the night
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Willie Maley, Four Leaf Clover
Everyone.......11
-
SOUTHSTANDFRONT
- Joined:
- May 25, 2007
- Messages:
- 1,035
- Likes Received:
- 1
- Location:
- ayrshire
- Fav Celtic Player:
- artur boruc
Boruc...8 had nothing to do and left exposed for the goal
Hinkel...7 decent game,got forward well
Naylor...6 his usual b4 getting injured Wilson...7 looked composed
Caldwell...8 one of his better nights,though he should have * weir at the end
McManus...7 defended well but his distribution remains a concern
Hartley...8 fought for every ball,gritty performance
Robson...8 unlucky to be subbed,got stuck right in
Nakamura...8 solid game and what a goal!!!
McGeady...8 was doubled up on all game but done well
JVOH...8 won his fair share in the air,decent performance
McDonald...6 looks a little lost at the moment
<!-- / message --><!-- sig --> -
Dempsey
- Joined:
- Jul 29, 2005
- Messages:
- 26,686
- Likes Received:
- 4
- Location:
- Tiobraid Arann, Eire
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Boruc & McGeady
- Fav Celtic Song:
- Fields of Athenry
Boruc - 6, Nothing really to do and conceded their only decent shot with dodgy positioning
Hinkel - 7, Solid, no mistakes
Naylor - 7, Played better than usual
Caldwell - 8, Very good contribution at the back and for the goals, showed hunger
McManus - 7, Solid but lost sight of Darcheville before lunging a block, could have had another OG TBH
Nakamura - 8, Excellent Goal and showed good passes and movement
McGeady - 7, Too much of the play aim down his wing and he was predictable because of it. Not his fault but that what it was
Hartley - 8, Who said this guy cant play DM?
Robson - 8, His tackle on Dailly sumed up his attitude and showed good intellegence going forward, easy see why he was nominated for POTY
Hesselink - 8, Could have done better in open play but he had a tough job, priceless goal
McDonald - 7, The penalty could have made him a hero but misses happen it wasnt a bad peno but made up for it with the header to JVOH
Wilson - 6.5, Looked good going forward but lacks match practice and it showed. Shouldn't have attacked the ball for their goal without anyone covering. (Was a free for me before that, though) -
irvy7
- Joined:
- Apr 23, 2005
- Messages:
- 6,536
- Likes Received:
- 1
- Location:
- scotland ayr
- Fav Celtic Player:
- brown,cauldwell
- Fav Celtic Song:
- ynwa
loving the praise for caldwell he is still young and looked like he was wearing his heart on his sleave
-
Boruc - 7 I like the way he lead the charge at the end. Did nothing wrong
Hinkle - 7 Gradually liking him. became more of a force when needed in 2nd half
Naylor - 3/5 Good defensively in 1st half. Didn't help McGeady enough
McManus 7 - Good headers and tackles
Caldwell 7 - Really good 2nd half. 1st had fears of being bossed but coped well with fouls
Hartley 6 - Played a part which we haven't had since Donati signed but could be better
Robson 8 - Brilliant display from an experienced player who has everything in his game. Would be player of the season if still at D utd
McGeady 6 - Always as ever looked dangerous but apart from 2nd half cross one cross lost possession for the most
McDonald 6 - Not at his best touch wise but gave the defenders something to think about and set the winning goal up
VOH - 6 Battled away but not enough in the way of touch or vision. The timing of the goal was class though!
Naka - 9 Best player on the pitch..simple as. Set one up. Scored goal of the season and beautifully got Cuellar sent off. WORLD CLASS. -
steph020582
- Joined:
- Feb 23, 2007
- Messages:
- 892
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- South Side
- Fav Celtic Player:
- McGeady
Caldwell set up the winner! -
Boruc 6 - not much to do, maybe could have done better with the goal
Hinkel 6 - Went forward well got stuck in decent performance
McManus 7 - Quite a solid game, he would have a got a 10 rating if he kicked the * out of Ferguson
Caldwell 8 - Brilliant imo setup celtics first, involved in the 2nd, got stuck in, solid display in defence
Naylor 7 - actually played very well but had to come off at half-time
Nakmura 9 - MOTM, scored a beastly goal and harshly didnt get a 2nd Brill Performance
Robson 7 - played very well again not scared to go in for tackles
Hartley 8 - another good perfromace at the holding role for Hartley
McGeadY 8 - good night again for Mcgeady dribbling was superb needs to pass quicker though
V OF H 7 - lol didint do much for full game and pops up and wins us game, but h gets a 7 for tht
McDonald 7 - had a few chances, even though he missed a crucial penalty he didnt give up and setup V Of H's goal
SUBS
Samaras 6 - Missed a glancing header maybe chould have got it on target at least
Wilson 6 - out of position for rangers goal, looked rusty but made some good passes -
for me if he stayed on robson would have been my motm
-
Boruc 6 - Nothing to do really
Hinkel 7 - Looks as if he'll be our long term right back, i like the look of him!
McManus 7 - Dependable passing was poor again though
Caldwell 9 - His long passing is superb, if he scrubs out the occasional school boy stuff he'll be a player for Celtic
Naylor 7 - Was playing well passing was far better
Nakmura 9 - The wee man delivered, thank you Naka.
Robson 8 - Has to be a mainstay, classy and gives you dig
Hartley 8 - Stuck to his task and won his battles, passing immaculate.
McGeady 7 - Overcooked it a few times, time to revert back to going to the byline at every opportunity, he's went back into his shell as concerns his belief in his own pace.
Hesselink 8 - PLayed well and won the game at the death
McDonald 6 - Missed the penalty and his touch was terrible, i think we need to take the wee man out the firing line for a couple of games for his own good.
SUBS
Samaras 6 - Looked like a man with a point to prove, ally that to his ability and he may bee crucial in the run in
Wilson 5 - Out of position and he's not the answer at left back, hopefully Lee's o.k
Strachan 10 - He made the wrong decision in bringing off Robson imo but he got the last laugh and the Smith monkey is off his back for that and that only he gets a 10. -
also have to say thought caldwell was great passing , tackling , heading the lot did it well
-
already a thread bhoys
http://www.talkceltic.net/forum/celtic-chat/35036-player-ratings.html -
bowroadbhoy
- Joined:
- May 20, 2005
- Messages:
- 791
- Likes Received:
- 74
- Location:
- Northampton
- Fav Celtic Player:
- Jinky
- Fav Celtic Song:
- The Celtic Song, Oh' Hampden in the sun,Fields of Athenry
Boruc...5
Hinkel...7
Naylor...7 Wilson...7
Caldwell...8
McManus...7
Hartley...8
Robson...8
Nakamura...8
McGeady...7
JVOH...6
McDonald...6
<!-- / message --><!-- sig --> -
ronnie1uk
- Joined:
- Mar 30, 2006
- Messages:
- 389
- Likes Received:
- 0
- Location:
- Here & there
- Fav Celtic Player:
- James Forrest
- Fav Celtic Song:
- YNWA
Boruc...5
Hinkel...8
Naylor...7 Wilson...6
Caldwell...8
McManus...7
Hartley...8
Robson...8
Naka...9 [20 for his goal ]
McGeady...8
VOH.....7 [ 10 for his goal ]
Skippy....6
Were not giving the league up for THEM -
every man a winner .............hail hail proud of u all
Page 1 of 2