Adam Matthews

Did well.

Solid at the back and a threat going forward.

High hopes for the bhoy.

 

Thought he done well, didn't get tested in defence though but going forward he looked a good player

 

He will turn out to be a good signing, was gutted when he left cardiff but could not have gone to a better club than celtic

 

I thought he was one of our better players today

 

Impressive again.

Bit prone to poor decision making but that will improve. Looks neat on the ball. I like that.

 

Looks like he shites himself when he gets the ball.

Nothing from him so far that has pleased me.

 

Lot of talent in there, I think he well develop well from what Ive seen.

 

When he had the ball on the wing and ended up in the centre he didnt have a clue, maybe it never happened at Cardiff but he's only young he will develop.

 

Played well i thought, good going forward.

 

I'm not writing him off yet, but I haven't seen anything that noteworthy of praise either tbh

 

Very good competition for Wilson. I think he'll be a big player for us in the future.

 

impressed

 

Looked like Mark Wilson but with an extra yard of pace.

 

I've liked the look of him so far in pre-season, but I thought he was quite suspect positionally today. He was caught too far forward, leaving space in behind and a player unmarked; this happened a few times. He was also at fault for playing someone on-side at one point I thought.

I am very critical though!

 

I thught he was only so-so today, TBH. He made one or 2 slips, which resulted in a corner & a throw from a threatening position. Thankfully nothing came of either, but IMO there is improvement needed, especially in his defensive duties, if he is to supplant Mark Wilson as first choice.

 

He was very good going forward, good technical skills as well, little bit nervous when magennis was running at him but he has a lot of time to hone his defensive skills, thought he did well overall.

 

i actually thought he looked pretty comfartable on the ball!

 

Decent with the ball at feet and has plenty of energy and pace wouldn't be confident going into Europe or away to tougher spl teams with him though

 

thought he was brilliant today MOTM for me