Discussion in 'Competition Corner' started by JC Anton, Mar 19, 2019.
Discuss Mafia 45 - Shawshank Redemption in the Competition Corner area at TalkCeltic.net.
That's my thinking as well.... two Mafia teams.
When’s the deadline? A lot of people sitting tight at the moment.
An interesting theory cooked up by two people who discarded Mafia..
How did you come to that conclusion?
You've lost me. You asked if big mafia discards could be sent back out. By definition that would require 2 PM's. I pointed out that that didn't happen to me. Both my roles were sent for me to choose from in a single message. If you received 2 messages with role options then maybe you got one of these big mafia discards as an option.
A lot of scum discards there and if Obaf is to be believed there will definitely be a few who got offered 2 scum roles.
How likely is it someone gets offered 2 VT’s? Guessing the roles are just randomised to numbers?
Possibly just to balance out the game.
Could have been a lot of scum picked and Anton wanted to add another Townie but not make town too overpowered so gave Obaf VT.
Or it was just purely random and unlucky for Olaf.
Deadline tomorrow at 10pm.
Can’t see us gaining much info from here until then considering the discards and lack of activity.
Would anyone be up for a majority vote? We all put forward one name each and whoever gets most votes is shivved..
A logical one none the less, 8 mafia discards with 17 players is a lot considering theres a chance some of the mafia rejects will of been offered two mafia roles and obviously others will of taken mafia ect, maybe not just a thought because of the discards.
I'm up for a majority vote although like most day 1's its all just guess work at moment and people with poweroles as per are going to be key
Plenty of time to come to a majority. Only Dazza and Scotia I'm taking as town just now. Sorry Keano & V as well, for now.
I ain't got a clue what V is, I'm suspicious of him 90% of the time, but yet again I am Town.....I'll flip Town, 100%.
Bullshit, that's not what I was implying at all Che, FFS.....I asked if it was possibly that Mafia discards were offered out, not as a secondary pm, just offered to players to choose from, I didn't mention anything of two PM's, you are the one that brought and continue to bring up two PM's.
I was questioning your wording around two roles, asking if you had two roles, not asking if you had two PM's, I suggest you go back and read my posts.
That's interesting? Care to explain how you are reading them as Town?
Maybe in your faction?
Sean M x 1 (Tim)
Pablo x 1 (Dazza)
9 Required for a Lynch, Deadline 2200 Thursday.
Marie more defensive than usual
Editing his post.....seriously?!
Can't be frigging doing that!
I'm the same defensive way I always am, fact of the matter is that there is very little being said and someone has to try get people talking.
Fair enough Marie.
Maybe in reading too much into it.
You are if you are thinking I'm more defensive, I'll always defend myself robustly.....well when I'm Town, I crumble as scum.