Discussion in 'Competition Corner' started by JC Anton, Mar 19, 2019.
Discuss Mafia 45 - Shawshank Redemption in the Competition Corner area at TalkCeltic.net.
One of the best films ever @Marie , honestly
Nah, not seen that either.....the rap factor put me right off.
So I keep hearing, don't know how many folk over the years have said that.
Don't know why is just hasn't appealed to me
Anyway...attaching this as a file so I do t need to type it out.
List of discards by faction....started with the VT and Goon roles as listed by Pablo is out of place in the order
There's VT in there who have taken scum roles....also... Goons who have better scum roles ( although what the * is better than strongman and Godfather, I don't know).
ha ha I will come back to this another time , dont want to derail the thread .
You were offered two VT roles?
I was told I was a VT and that's it. Anton never told me of a discard, likely because it was 2. I didn't even realize it was a greater edition until he just made the first post.
That makes sense that you were just told you were VT....
so we have che saying he was offered 2 roles and obaf claiming only 1 .
So Che is not a VT, but he also didn't claim to be
Yeah, I don't get Che's post at all....not actually buying that he has two roles, that's too much of a coincidence, he had two roles in the last game.
Yeah, true but do you think it's likely that he has two roles again?
I read "two roles" as VT and whatever he chose. VT is still a role.
That's the norm to get offered two roles at the same time and then discard one, except in your case( if that was the case)
Has anyone ever been offered a role, one role, then a while later, gets another pm offering an other role?
Sure but my two were the same, apparently, so Anton didn't bother giving me a choice. Makes sense for brevity. Che had an actual choice to make. I'm sure most of you did.
Yeah, I'm not disputing that he had a choice and I need to take your word on the fact you didn't, would be very niave of me to take you at your word on Day 1.
Maybe it was just his wording that is off, or maybe I'm reading too much into his wording, I'm just highlighting the fact he said he was offered his two roles at the same time, that's the norm, it's left it open to interpretation, in my opinion.
I'm a paranoid * that nit picks on stupid details, which in fairness, can be clues.
bit of soft shoe shuffling obaf , " I was told I was VT and thats it " couple of posts later " sure but my two were the same "
I'm away to do housework upstairs, going to miss JC playing as he's always in about it and digging.
Will check in later X
Surprised Dazza and V discarded big scum roles in Serial Killer and Strongman.
My reason for discarding Godfather was that I’ve been scum the past 2 games and thought I’d switch it up.