If 1 had to go

If you were manager, and the board came to you and said that we would have to sell someone to make money before we could spend it, who would you sell?????


BORUC OR McGEADY

 

mcgeady.

 

McGeady without a doubt

 

I'd sell McGeady regardless of if the board told me that or not.

 

McGeady - Good on his day but Arthur is ireplaceable to us. He has to be one of the best in the world. I can only recal him making a few mistakes

 

McGeady.

Boruc has been poor for a while accept the last few games but we all know how he can play at his best.

McGeady's end product is very frustrating.

 

I would quite happily let mcgeady go for 4 or 5m as i cant see us getting much more for him as if the majority of our supporters can see he is over rated with no end product then i am pretty sure the managers in england can see the same and i cant see anyone paying the reported 8m the papers say mcleish is supposed to be offering although for 8m i would throw brown and samaras into the deal to get rid them as well.

 

None!

Simple NEITHER! Is that a big enough reply!!

 

NAW LOL

 

That was funny!

 

McGeady. I would NEVER sell Boruc.

 

Don't think we'd miss any of them too much. Boruc nowadays has more bad games than good, although that's changed recently. Same applies to McGeady, has several good games in a row then falls away. Like every other season.

We'd be able to replace McGeady, using the money we get for him. And we'd replace Boruc with Zaluska.

If I had to sell and keep one, I'd keep McGeady.

 

how the * do you grt the writeing big like that? anyawy id punt mcgeady

 

Would look to sell Brown before looking to sell either of these 2, but if push came to shove in a choice between them, would sell McGeady. That said, nobody is bigger than the team and the fact is every player has a selling price.

 

Right here goes i thought Boruc's time was up a while ago,
but right now i would get shot of mc geady before him as this boy is
showing no signs of getting better

 

a voted for bourc but i widnae be 2 fussed if both them went be gd to take a bit of cash from them then get 2 mabe 3 great defenders like big bobo ur myjalby and i think we have quite a solid midfield were just missing a wee bit of flare and even low mcgeady gives that he cant cross the ball :Z

 

Think we have just as good a keeper in Zaluska as we do with Boruc, one's just worth a lot more than the other.

 

3 weeks ago the vast majority would be going for Boruc.


The fickle nature of football fans.

 

McGeady.

Better wingers than McGeady can be picked up with a bit of decent scouting, but keepers of Boruc's ability are rare as gold dust.

Goalkeepers are also generally undervalued in the transfer market, and McGeady would be worth a better deal.

 

McGeady due to the fact he'd have a higher selling value plus he's been * hopeless and far from his best for a couple of seasons now.