Ambrose vs Boyata: Battle of the Bombscares

Efe, his pace is outstanding.

 

Boyata, comfortably.

Ambrose has been costing us goals and games for a couple of years now. Out of his depth against part timers. Diddy.

 

I'm not so sure he's better in the air, Efe has cleared a lot of incoming. Plus Efe definitely has a better pass forward.

 

Personally I think Efe is hopeless in the air. Half of his header clearances end up going high rather than far, and his heading in the oppositions box...dreadful. 50p piece head.

 

Efe, he's proven he can do well in the past. In fact I think he and Toure could do well alongside each other. Boyata on the other hand has shown absolutely nothing to suggest he can be a good defender, we took a punt on him because we assumed because he was at City that he's a good player at least but there's a reason he's played * all in his career.

Our defensive options should be Erik, Kolo, Jozo, Efe, O'Connell and Ajer (to fill in if needs be). Don't give Mulgrew a new contract and sell Boyata to some naive English championship team.

 

Efe should be gone aswell. He makes too many mistakes. You and wanyama only like him because he seems like a nice guy.

 

I meant his positioning to clear headers, who cares where they land as long as the danger is cleared.

 

I agree O'Connell looks like he could be a player as well as McCart. I would get rid of both Efe and Boyata but I think Efe is the more accomplished player.

McIntyre has done well with the youth, they can clear a ball and they are comfortable moving it forward.

 

Aye but the problem is plenty of the time the danger isn't cleared. He's a total diddy who can't be trusted against part timers.

I'll rejoice the day he's sold.

 

I'll rejoice the day he is replaced with better quality.

 

Ambrose is finished here after his latest showings. Boyata has not even had a chance yet to impress Rodgers yet. So on that basis "talk to me" Efe Ambrose should be first out the door.

 

ffs ambrose..... man, if he could cut out them cheap goals he gifts to the opposition i'd give him a contract for life

boyata average player more consistent defender that doesn't gift anywhere near the same amount of goals as ambrose

think boyata would have to be the choice to keep..... because for as long as we have had efe he hasn't shrugged off the poor defending errors infact your waiting for the mistake every game he plays unfortunately.

Thing is i think we are better going forward with efe in the team i guess he takes chances and maybe that's why he gets beat so often at the back

 

Boyata's the better player and has proven a solid defender. He had his moments of poor play, and IMO is not up to the quality we need.

Ambrose has pace... Thats it.

So thats my take on it lol.

 

Boyata.

 

boyata shouldnt even be classed in the same bracket yet as ambrose.

boyata was reliable last year apart from the old firm which then turned out to be an injury anyway.boyata banged a few in last year aswell maybe 4 or 5 goals.

boyata has just had his first full season in football under his belt and he done well but nothing special in my eyes.im hoping he can improve this year,also having brendan rodgers as manager might work wonders for him this year.

i dont even no why this is bein debated.