Who do you believe is Celtics most valuable player

If you look at the previous messages mate i said in money terms

 

Look at the previous messages mate. On the first page i explained what i meant if you read that

 

I would have said Boruc after his great display in his 3 games in the Euros in the summer with Poland, however he's sold a lot of goals this season which may have put buyers off bidding high for him. I do believe he'll come good again and it will be better for us in the long run to hold onto him.

Scott Brown is the player, who if I were a manager down south for example would be watching right now. I could see an Everton or a similar team bidding 10-12 million for him. He has been sensational this season for club and country and can play at the top level. He's a Gattuso with pace!

After these two I don't know. If it were true about a team coming in for VOH - 7m, then it's him followed by McDonald who i value highly. It's no fluke scoring 35 goals for Celtic, scoring into AC Milan, Man Utd and the huns.

 

Good point about mcdonald mate. Thats true, some people seem to forget what he did last season (and i for one am one of those people). I just think the 2 big lads are better strikers at the minute.

 

scott brown

 

I wouldn't argue with that mate as Samaras has plenty of time to prove himself being in his early 20s. We have good options for the SPL anyway and hopefully a good UEFA Cup run as well.

 

Agreed

 

Artur, because he simply cannot be replaced.

others can.

 

Agreed

 

i never voted as i think there is 3 ,and they are ,boruc,caldwell,brown

 

hoo the * voted naylor

 

Big Artureasy! Transfer market value and to the team.

 

The heid has been excellent since March and i am glad i was wrong bout him.

 

oh rite sorry lad i thought u ment something else

 

Big Arthur but Scott Brown is pushing him this season IMO I see either of them picking up Player Of The Year if this form continues!