1. Having trouble logging in by clicking the link at the top right of the page? Click here to be taken to the log in page.
    Dismiss Notice

XI Valuation

Discussion in 'Transfer Rumours' started by Hammy89, May 6, 2008.

  1. Hammy89

    Hammy89 Gold Member Gold Member

    Messages:
    20,784
    Location:
    Paradise
    what do you think of players valuation whom have appeared in our last two fixtures?

    My Valuations
    Boruc - £12.5m
    Hinkel - £2.5m
    Caldwell - £3m
    O'Dea - £1m
    McManus - £3.5m
    Naylor - £750k
    Wilson - £1m
    Nakamura - £4m
    Brown - £5m
    Hartley - £1m
    Robson - £2m
    McGeady - £9m
    VoH - £1.5m
    Samaras - £2.5m
    McDonald - £5m
     
  2. Rosco67

    Rosco67

    Messages:
    6,132
    Location:
    Dumfries, Scotland
    My Valuations
    Boruc - £11 million
    Hinkel - £2.5million
    Caldwell - £1.5million
    O'Dea - £1million
    McManus - £4million
    Naylor - £1million
    Wilson - £2m
    Nakamura - £4m
    Brown - £5m
    Hartley - £1m
    Robson - £1.5m
    McGeady - £8m
    VoH - £3million
    Samaras - £2.5m
    McDonald - £5m

    Not far from what you put. Can never really truly guess a players proper valuation due to the silly prices people will pay these days.
     
  3. Hammy89

    Hammy89 Gold Member Gold Member

    Messages:
    20,784
    Location:
    Paradise
    very true. but its only a bit of fun.
     
  4. Fiferbhoy1991

    Fiferbhoy1991

    Messages:
    6,753
    Location:
    SSR Fife
    My opinion

    Boruc-12 Million
    Hinkel-3 million
    Caldwell-1 million
    O'Dea-2 million
    McManus-3.5 million
    Naylor-750k
    Wilson-1.5 million
    Nakamura-3.5 million
    Brown-5 million
    Hartley-800k
    Robson-1.5 million
    McGeady-9 million
    JVoH-3 million
    Samaras-3.5 million
    McDonald-4 million
     
  5. HULK

    HULK

    Messages:
    480
    Location:
    ontario, canada
    Boruc - £12 million
    Hinkel - £2.5million
    Caldwell - £1.5million
    O'Dea - £2million
    McManus - £4million
    Naylor - £1million
    Wilson - £2m
    Nakamura - £6m
    Brown - £5m
    Hartley - £1m
    Robson - £2.5m
    McGeady - £10m
    VoH - £3m
    Samaras - £3m
    McDonald - £5m
     
  6. greg2467

    greg2467

    Messages:
    2,175
    Location:
    Ireland
    Boruc- £12m
    Hinkel- £3m
    Wilson- £1m
    Naylor- £1m
    Mick- £3m
    Caldwell- £1.5m
    O' Dea- £1m
    Balde- £1m
    Naka- £5m
    McGeady- £9m
    Hartley- £1.5m
    Brown- £5m
    Donati -£2m
    Robson- £2.5m
    JVOH- £3m
    Skippy- £5m
    Samaras- £2.5m
     
  7. hoopymo

    hoopymo

    Messages:
    8,152
    Location:
    near hampden
    the whole team-priceless
     
  8. gibby150

    gibby150

    Messages:
    502
    Location:
    motherwell
    here`s mine
    ..
    My Valuations
    Boruc - £11m
    Hinkel - £3m
    Caldwell - £1.5m
    O'Dea - £1m
    McManus - £3.5m
    Naylor - £1.5k
    Wilson - £1m
    Nakamura - £4.5m
    Brown - £5.5m
    Hartley - £1.5m
    Robson - £2m
    McGeady - £10m
    VoH - £2.2m
    Samaras - £3m
    McDonald - £6m
     
  9. Heres mine

    Boruc - £12m
    Hinkel - £2m
    Caldwell - £2m
    O'Dea - £1.5
    McManus - £3m
    Naylor - £850k
    Wilson - £1.5m
    Nakamura - £5m
    Brown - £5m
    Hartley - £2m
    Robson - £2m
    McGeady - £9.5m
    VoH - £2m
    Samaras - £3m
    McDonald - £5m
     
  10. Rossenspeil

    Rossenspeil

    Messages:
    12,084
    Location:
    Button Moon
    if anyone wants to offer more than £1m for Caldwell Im happy to drive him there myself!
     
  11. Dazza

    Dazza

    Messages:
    11,678
    Boruc - £12m
    Hinkel - £1.5m
    Caldwell - £2m
    O'Dea - £1m
    McManus - £3m
    Naylor - £500k
    Wilson - £1.5m
    Nakamura - £2.5m
    Brown - £5m
    Hartley - £1m
    Robson - £2m
    McGeady - £10m
    VoH - £2.5m
    Samaras - £3m
    McDonald - £4m
    3-in-a-row - priceless



    PS. Rossen, that's why you are not a manager. Caldwell has been one of our better players as of late
     
    Last edited by a moderator: May 6, 2008
  12. Paddy

    Paddy

    Messages:
    1,812
    i'd carry him,but to be fair he seems to have bucked his ideas up lately.

    Anyway a player is only worth what another team is prepared to pay for him, so there could be some real shocks in the valuation of the players. I think the jewel in the crown being Boruc, and he could go for some serious money as it's very hard to find a quality keeper anywhere in the world