Scott McDonald-yay or nae?

Is Scott McDonald a good buy for Celtic FC?

 

Because we really need another thread like?
Possibly, although he gets my full support and backing

 

I think so... hes a decent squad player!
ask me at the end of next season..........

 

not really.. i think he's not good enoughh. soorry

 

Mebbes aye mebbes naw

 

Hes not a good buy IMO, i dont think hes good enough for celtic

Having said that hes a celtic player now and i hope he proves me wrong and does well.

 

Where's the 'washing my hair' option?

 

Quite simply.......no

 

undecided will judge him when he plays,but he might surprise us he's similar to miller but a * of a lot tougher and a better finisher.

 

he'll do a decent job, but even tho i dont rate him highly i will reserve my judgment until he wears the hoops

 

Yeh i think he will be a good squad player and will help pull the club thro rough patches like we have the now!
I would bank on him scoring more than beatie n miller

 

I don't really see the problem here. We've signed a guy with a proven goalscoring record. He is 23 years of age and already this season he has scored more than Miller and Magic together. If he doesn't work out we can move him on for profit. Obviously we would like to sign bigger names and better players but it is not always possible. If he scores half the goals that ex Motherwell players such as McBride, Deans and McClair scored then he will be excellent.

 

lot of goals in him i'm happy

 

Seemed like an odd buy from GS considering we already have many strikers firing blanks, didn't think we really needed another one. He came cheap though and can score goals when given the chance! Hopefuly with better players around him he'll turn good but we'll have to wait and see.

 

I think he could do well for us but as always we will have to wait and see what happens. Keep the faith the guys not even arrived yet. And he can score goals (as if we need reminding)

 

Where the i want to kill Strachan for signing the wee * option?

 

over 1/2 a million quid os a bit of a gamble if you ask me, I don't really rate him or even like his style - he also dives quite a lot which I don't like.

I'm obviously going to give him my backing like I do to all the guys from the Scottish league who I didn;t really like - Riorden, Hartley, Pressley.
So he'll really have to prove himself to us, before we can answer the question.
He reminds me of Nacho Novo, going from Dundee to Rangers...aye brilliant buy!!

 

YES.............

 

He has scored 2 more than Magic i think, and to be fair Magic has missed an awful lot of football.

 

well i havent really like heard of him before but im sure if celtic like thought he would be good with us i have to trust them