Miller Or zurawski ,Who Ahead Of Who ???

For me TBO - its gotta be Miller for me... Magic is really crap at the moment

 

the goals speak for magic, everything else is useless

 

thow in jj and its 9 men

 

Finally, someone who's on Zurawski's side...good lad Marty He can score the goals if the chances are given to him. Im sure he would have scored the chances Miller missed in Copenhagen!

 

most of the arguments are based on personal emotions rather than objective reasons. Miller doesn't seem to be skillful enough for celtic.

 

I can agree to an extent ... I think Millers best position is in a counter attacking side, and is probably the best option away from home...

 

I can agree with this. Also, away from home he's the player who you'll have on for most of the game pressuring defenders into mistakes and making runs for a quick ball.

 

JJ bashing is uncalled for he has scored a couple of important goals playing out posistion in his 1st season, Zuraskwi is incapable of beating a man, he can't run away from defenders to get one-on-one and has a horrific 1st touch

Beattie is the mix of both Miller and Zuraswki he can finish, has decent pace however he is good in the air, can put himself about and scores important goals which Zuraswki and Miller temd not to do

 

Miller.......only a couple of months back - it was him who we were relying on in the champions league and he done us proud - had a few off games since though but i still think he makes alot more of a contrabution than a few players (inc Magic) and he does well with setting up, running at defenders and (from what i've seen) can hold the ball up well if he needs to - think the partnership with Jan will come good

 

Although I am Miller biased, I would say one thing i've noticed. The longer either one of this pair plays and the other doesnt, the lower the popularity of the one playing gets and the other guy not playing slowly seems a better option. This happened to Kenny, now its happening to Magic.

 

this thread is a joke. Miller Magic this, Miller Magic that...
We got Riordan, proven goalscorer!!
SUch a waste of talent to see him on the bench. It would be ok to argue Miller or Magic, if we would have anybody else to choose from.

we got Riordan and Beattie. Leave Keny and Majic alone and let them rebiuld their form.

 

Someone who knows how many minutes they have played each? (not caps, but minutes)

Actully I think Miller is the better player against good teams as the Huns, in Champions League etc. and attacking teams in general. Miller needs space to run in...
Where Magic is good when we playing bad teams and when we got the most possession. Like the Dumbarton game. And the last part of the games when the opponent gets tired.

 

I'd pick Kenny over Magic

 

fucken kenny for sure, he has been a stae in the chapions league

 

miller before zurawski miller runs round and retrieves so many balls for us and we need some more wing play that the option miller gives justs needs to get a few goals zurawski needs to step it up not been doing much this past while as alot of people have said before its like playing with 10 men he just doesnt seem to do enough

 

They're both * but at least Miller works hard and is a big game player.

 

Am pickin Miller because he's the one that's not been proving he's * recently, Zurawski is.

Get them both to *, this window!!

 

miller of course my favorite plaayer but when he has a good form

 

Miller is like a car without an engine. nice to show, but after a few days it becomes boring and even annoying, because it can't be driven. at least magic is a fiat...

 

good imagination bud ...MAGIC for me every day of the week..hes needs confidence and no pressure from "headless chickens" out running him