1. Having trouble logging in by clicking the link at the top right of the page? Click here to be taken to the log in page.
    Dismiss Notice

should i stay or should i go

Discussion in 'Celtic Chat' started by Twisty, May 7, 2011.

Discuss should i stay or should i go in the Celtic Chat area at TalkCeltic.net.

  1. murphy1967

    Joined:
    Jul 9, 2010
    Messages:
    813
    Likes Received:
    0
    no it wouldnt we are talking the mginns and cervis etc arseholes who only want there paychecks and replacing them with guys like templeton and conway etc real hungry players
     
  2. Mystic Penguin

    Joined:
    Sep 10, 2009
    Messages:
    21,399
    Likes Received:
    2,000
    Location:
    Republic of North Lanarkshire
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Samaras
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Amhrán na bhFiann
    forster-Go
    zaluska-Stay
    cervi-Go
    hinkel-Stay
    wilson-Stay
    cha-Go
    mulgrew-Stay
    maj-Go
    loovens-Go
    o'dea-Go
    thompson-Go
    izzy-Stay
    rogne-Stay
    brown-Stay
    commons-Stay
    forrest-Stay
    juarez-Stay
    kayal-Stay
    ledley-Stay
    ljunberg-Go
    maloney-Go
    mccourt-Go
    mcginn-Go
    ki-Go
    stokes-Stay
    hooper-Stay
    samaras-Stay unless we get a decent bid for him
    murphy-Go
    mcgowan-Go
    rasmussen-Go
     
  3. JrOhara2

    Joined:
    Sep 12, 2008
    Messages:
    1,491
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Glasgow, Scotland & Vancouver, Canada
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Broon, Ledley, Kayal, Big Jos, Hooper, Murphy
    Fav Celtic Song:
    YNWA, Let the people sing
    forster-stay
    zaluska-go
    cervi-loan
    hinkel-go
    wilson-stay
    cha-stay
    mulgrew-stay
    maj-stay
    loovens-go
    o'dea-go
    thompson-stay
    izzy-STAY
    rogne-stay
    brown-stay
    commons-stay
    forrest-stay
    juarez-stay
    kayal-stay
    ledley-stay
    ljunberg-stay
    maloney-stay
    mccourt-go
    mcginn-go
    ki-stay
    stokes-stay
    hooper-stay
    samaras-stay
    murphy-go
    mcgowan-go
    rasmussen-go
     
  4. Metlson

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2010
    Messages:
    2,125
    Likes Received:
    84
    Location:
    Australia
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Tom Rogic
    Fav Celtic Song:
    YNWA
    forster- Depending on price and other options
    zaluska- Could do better, Ok back up
    cervi- Go
    hinkel- Would love hinkel to stay but one of him cha and wilson will have to go
    wilson- same as above
    cha- same as above
    mulgrew- stay
    maj- stay
    loovens- go
    o'dea- go
    thompson- meh
    izzy- stay
    rogne-stay
    brown-stay
    commons-stay
    forrest-stay
    juarez-stay if he is used if not then get some money for a striker
    kayal-stay
    ledley-stay
    ljunberg-meh
    maloney-stay
    mccourt-meh
    mcginn-meh
    ki-stay
    stokes-stay
    hooper-stay
    samaras-meh
    murphy-meh
    mcgowan-meh
    rasmussen-meh
     
  5. trip2themoon Concomitant Allez-Vous?

    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2011
    Messages:
    9,160
    Likes Received:
    2,779
    Location:
    North Britain
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Peter Grant
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Boys of the Old Brigade
    forster- Bye
    zaluska-Keep
    cervi-Didn't know he was a goalie til I read this thread..:52: So bye...
    hinkel-Bye
    wilson-Keep
    cha-Bye
    mulgrew-Keep
    maj-Bye
    loovens-Bye
    o'dea-Keep
    thompson-Bye
    izzy-Must Keep
    rogne-Keep
    brown-Bye
    commons-Must Keep
    forrest-Keep
    juarez-Dunno, maybe get rid to free up some wages
    kayal-Must Keep
    ledley-Keep
    ljunberg-* off off our wage bill
    maloney-Let someone else pay his wage and physio
    mccourt-Keep
    mcginn-Bye (not Celtic class)
    ki-Keep
    stokes-Keep
    hooper-Keep
    samaras-Love to see him off the wage bill but who'd want him?
    murphy-Bye
    mcgowan-Bye
    rasmussen-Keep (surely he'd score more than Sammy)
     
  6. celtic croatia

    Joined:
    Oct 25, 2010
    Messages:
    1,219
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Zagreb, Croatia
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Neil Lennon
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Let The People Sing
    forster- depends on price
    zaluska- stay
    cervi- go
    hinkel- stay if possible
    wilson- stay
    cha- go
    mulgrew- stay
    maj- go
    loovens- go
    o'dea- go
    thompson- go
    izzy- stay
    rogne- stay
    brown- stay
    commons- stay
    forrest- stay
    juarez- go
    kayal- stay
    ledley- stay
    ljunberg- go
    maloney- stay
    mccourt- stay
    mcginn- go
    ki- stay
    stokes- stay
    hooper- stay
    samaras- stay
    murphy- go
    mcgowan-go
    rasmussen-go
     
  7. Mr. Slippyfist

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2009
    Messages:
    7,171
    Likes Received:
    10,068
    forster- Go
    zaluska-Go
    cervi- Go
    hinkel- Wants to go
    wilson-Stay
    cha-Stay
    mulgrew- Stay
    maj- Stay
    loovens- GO!!!!!!!
    o'dea- Go
    thompson- Stay
    izzy- Stay
    rogne- Stay
    brown- Go
    commons- Stay
    forrest- Stay
    juarez- Stay
    kayal- Stay
    ledley- Stay
    ljunberg- Go
    maloney-Go
    mccourt- Stay
    mcginn- Go
    ki- Stay
    stokes- Stay
    hooper- Stay
    samaras- Go
    murphy- Stay
    mcgowan- Go
    rasmussen-Stay

    [ /QUOTE]
     
  8. gafmcc

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2009
    Messages:
    42
    Likes Received:
    0
    forster- go
    zaluska- stay (backup)
    cervi- go
    hinkel- go
    wilson- stay
    cha- stay
    mulgrew- stay
    maj- stay
    loovens- go
    o'dea- go
    thompson- go
    izzy- stay
    rogne- stay
    brown- go
    commons- stay
    forrest- stay
    juarez- stay
    kayal- stay
    ledley- stay
    ljunberg- go
    maloney- go
    mccourt- go
    mcginn- go
    ki- stay
    stokes- stay
    hooper- stay
    samaras- go
    murphy- go
    mcgowan- go
    rasmussen- stay

    I absolutely detest Rangers and their 'style' of play but there are some things that they have done well and we should have a look at in our team.
    Having a good keeper is essential, McGregor had saved them off the top of my head 9-12 points at least this season. Steady centre half partnership which admittedley on paper has let in more goals however they seem to be less prone to silly basic errors. They have always had a prolific striker as well in Miller and now Jelavic. We don't at the moment.
    Hooper strikes the ball well but if he doesn't score he very rarely contributes much to the game. I think he would flourish next to a target man striker. Stokes unfortunately has been a big dissapointment for me but hopefully he will improve next season.
    If we sort out these positions then we will have a strong spine which should enable us to get results when we play poorly, which is something we haven't done that well this season.
    We MUST get rid of Brown and Maloney as they contribute zero to the team, especially Maloney. I don't know where this reputation comes from as far as I'm concerned he's done nothing in his full tenure at Celtic.
    If we sort those positions we will be good as we will have a strong spine to the team again. One CB, One Keeper and one prolific striker. Three quality players rather than five weak squad players and we will be good!!
     
  9. RyanR88

    Joined:
    May 5, 2011
    Messages:
    56
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Abz hi
    forster- Go
    zaluska- stay (Give him another chance)
    cervi- go
    hinkel- Keep
    wilson- stay
    cha- Go
    mulgrew- stay
    maj- stay
    loovens- Keep
    o'dea- Stay (He Smashed a hun, you know)
    thompson- go
    izzy- stay
    rogne- stay
    brown- go
    commons- stay
    forrest- stay
    juarez- stay
    kayal- stay
    ledley- stay
    ljungberg- Stay (He needs to get a chance)
    maloney- Stay
    mccourt- Stay
    mcginn- go
    ki- GTF (Utterly Useless most of the time)
    stokes- Go
    hooper- stay
    samaras- Please,Please GOOO!
    murphy- I dont care tbh?
    mcgowan- And who might you be?
    rasmussen- Yes stay
     
  10. Must.Be.Me

    Joined:
    Jan 5, 2011
    Messages:
    466
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Central Scotland
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Big Bad John
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Celtic Symphony
    Ones in bold should be sold or released. :bbpd:
     
  11. danderandan

    Joined:
    Dec 22, 2010
    Messages:
    148
    Likes Received:
    0
    an awful lot of people want majstorovic to stay can,t agree imo he has cost us more points than anyone imagine going into europe with big dan , nice big guy but not good enough .
     
  12. chanbhoy67

    Joined:
    Jun 30, 2008
    Messages:
    1,387
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Glasgow
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Let the people sing
    forster- Go
    zaluska- Go
    cervi- Go
    hinkel-Go
    wilson- Stay
    cha-Go
    mulgrew- Stay
    maj-Stay
    loovens- Go
    o'dea- Go
    thompson- Go
    izzy- Stay
    rogne- Stay
    brown- Stay
    commons- Stay
    forrest- stay
    juarez- stay
    kayal- stay
    ledley- stay
    ljunberg- go
    maloney- stay
    mccourt- stay
    mcginn- go
    ki- go
    stokes- stay
    hooper- stay
    samaras- go
    murphy- go
    mcgowan- go
    rasmussen- go
     
  13. Conor1888

    Joined:
    Jan 14, 2010
    Messages:
    3,343
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Belfast/Ireland
    forster-Go
    zaluska- Stay
    cervi-Stay
    hinkel- Go
    wilson- Stay
    cha- Stay
    mulgrew- Stay
    maj- Stay
    loovens- Go
    o'dea- Go
    thompson- Stay
    izzy- Stay
    rogne- Stay
    brown- Stay
    commons- Stay
    forrest- Stay
    juarez- Go (if hes not going to get a look in)
    kayal- Stay
    ledley- Stay
    ljunberg- Go
    maloney- Stay
    mccourt-Stay
    mcginn- Go
    ki- Go
    stokes- Stay
    hooper- Stay
    samaras-Go
    murphy-Stay (Been impressed from him in last view games)
    mcgowan- Go
    rasmussen-
    Go
     
  14. greengrocer

    Joined:
    Nov 28, 2009
    Messages:
    23,176
    Likes Received:
    7,050
    Location:
    In grocer shop
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Mjallby, Larsson, Lambert
    Forster - depends how much.
    zaluska- go
    cervi- go
    hinkel- go
    wilson- stay
    cha- go
    mulgrew- stay
    maj-stay
    loovens- go
    o'dea- go
    thompson- maybe stay
    izzy- stay
    rogne- stay
    brown-stay
    commons-stay
    forrest- stay
    juarez- loan out
    kayal- stay
    ledley- stay
    ljunberg- go
    maloney- stay
    mccourt- go
    mcginn- go
    ki- stay
    stokes- stay
    hooper-stay
    samaras- go
    murphy- go
    mcgowan- go
    rasmussen- go

    Don't see zaluska wanting to sit around the year again. Need 2 keepers. Get in a versatile fb to challenge izzy and Wilson. Got a cb coming in but cold do with another. And get a target man and winger.
     
  15. Shepard

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2009
    Messages:
    2,948
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Republic of North Lanarkshire
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Jimmy Johnstone
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Wolfetones - Celtic Symphony
    forster- Go
    zaluska- Stay
    cervi- Go
    hinkel- Go
    wilson- Stay
    cha- Stay
    mulgrew- Stay
    maj- Stay
    loovens- Go
    o'dea- Go
    thompson- Go
    izzy- Stay
    rogne- Stay
    brown- Stay
    commons- Stay
    forrest- Stay
    juarez- Go
    kayal- Stay
    ledley- Stay
    ljunberg- Go
    maloney- Stay
    mccourt- Go
    mcginn- Go
    ki- Stay
    stokes- Stay
    hooper- Stay
    samaras- Get tae *
    murphy- Maybe
    mcgowan- Go
    rasmussen- Go
     
  16. baileybhoy

    Joined:
    Sep 16, 2005
    Messages:
    1,511
    Likes Received:
    0
    Fav Celtic Song:
    I Just can't get enough
    this thread shows that we are carrying far too big a squad. thats just about 3 full teams ffs!
     
  17. Barry Robson

    Joined:
    May 20, 2008
    Messages:
    7,987
    Likes Received:
    591
    forster- STAY
    zaluska- GO
    cervi- GO
    hinkel- GO
    wilson- STAY
    cha- GO
    mulgrew- STAY
    maj- STAY
    loovens- GO
    o'dea- GO
    thompson- GO
    izzy- STAY
    rogne- STAY
    brown- STAY
    commons- STAY
    forrest- STAY
    juarez- GO
    kayal- STAY
    ledley- STAY
    ljunberg- GO
    maloney- GO
    mccourt- GO
    mcginn- GO
    ki- STAY
    stokes- STAY
    hooper- STAY
    samaras- GO
    murphy- GO
    mcgowan- GO
    rasmussen-GO
     
  18. Markybhoy

    Joined:
    Nov 9, 2008
    Messages:
    42,074
    Likes Received:
    3,702
    Fraser Forster - Stay. If Forster is available for less than £4million we should sign him.

    Lukasz Zaluska - Stay. If Zaluska is happy to play the role of backup GK then we should keep him.

    Dominic Cervi - Stay or go. I haven't seen enough of this guy to say whether he should stay or go.

    Andreas Hinkel - Go. Mark Wilson has made the right-back position his own and we have Adam Matthews arriving in the summer. Hinkel is on a big wage so keeping him in the squad would just be burning money.

    Mark Wilson - Stay. Wilson has been one of our most reliable performers this season.

    Cha Du-Ri - Go. A poor player. Don't rate him at all.

    Charlie Mulgrew - Stay. Mulgrew is a player well worth having in our squad.

    Daniel Majstorovic - Stay or Go. I would let Majstorovic go in the summer and bring in another quality centre-back to play alongside Kelvin Wilson next season. However, I wouldn't be too upset if he stayed on for one more season.

    Glenn Loovens - Go. Go now. Please.

    Darren O'Dea - Stay. I think O'Dea is a player worth having in the squad as a backup. He would have to understand that his first team opportunities will be pretty limited though.

    Josh Thompson - Go. He's slower than Davie Weir towing a caravan.

    Emilio Izaguirre - Stay. Obviously.

    Thomas Rogne - Stay. I think this lad could have a bright future at Celtic.

    Scott Brown - Stay. I think he's under appreciated by some Celtic fans. I like him.

    Efrain Juarez - Stay. Hopefully with a good pre-season under his belt we will see the best of Juarez next season. I think he could have something to offer.

    Beram Kayal - Stay. Our midfield general.

    Joe Ledley - Stay. His partnership with Kayal in the centre of midfield is key for us.

    Ki Sung-Yueng - Stay. I've not been blown away by what I've seen so far but I think there is more to come from Ki.

    Kris Commons - Stay. He's been a great signing.

    James Forrest - Stay. This lad has potential.

    Freddie Ljungberg - Go. Signing him was a waste of time and money.

    Shaun Maloney - Stay or Go. Maloney is a player worth having if he's fit. Unfortunately he always seems to be injured.

    Paddy McCourt - Stay. A handy player to have in the squad. He'll always be more of a super sub than a first team regular though.

    Niall McGinn - Go. I don't think he's going to make it at Celtic.

    Anthony Stokes - Stay. A regular goalscorer in the SPL.

    Gary Hooper - Stay. A good signing.

    Georgios Samaras - Go. Absolute circus act and a travesty of a footballer. Punt. Now.

    Daryl Murphy - Stay or go. I haven't seen enough of Murphy to make a fair judgement on him.

    Paul McGowan - Go. Never going to be good enough for Celtic.

    Morten Rasmussen - Go. Nothing against 'Razza' but I think his chances at Celtic are going to be limited so he should probably move on.


    Stay - 17.
    Stay or Go - 4.
    Go - 9.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: May 9, 2011
  19. PaulM1888 Moderator Moderator

    Joined:
    May 8, 2007
    Messages:
    71,152
    Likes Received:
    36,336
    Forster - Stay. Good keeper who will only get better.
    Zaluska - Stay. Good backup keeper.
    Cervi - Go. Red rotten.
    Hinkel - Go. Think he's a cracking full back but he was always leaving whenever he got fit again.
    Wilson - Stay. Steered clear of injury and put in a run of excellent performances.
    Cha - Stay. His pace is a crucial attribute in this squad, I think a lot of people undersell his worth.
    Mulgrew - Stay. Crucial squad member.
    Maj - Stay. Experienced leader.
    Loovens - Go. Always going to be the odd one out, clearly not trusted.
    O'Dea - Go. Not good enough.
    Thompson - Stay. Send out on loan, plenty of potential.
    Izzy - Stay. Top drawer full back.
    Rogne - Stay. Bags of potential and will only get better.
    Brown - Stay/Go. If a decent bid came in I would let him go.
    Commons - Stay. Look forward to seeing what he's capable of producing in a full season.
    Forrest - Stay. Completely lost all form since returning from injury but he has every attribute needed to be a top drawer winger.
    Juarez - Stay/Go. All down to his attitude really, if he wants to knuckle down he'd probably be a star here.
    Kayal - Stay. A midfield powerhouse, a guy you build a team around.
    Ledley - Stay. A class act in every sense of the word. Next season will hopefully produce more in terms of goals but in all other aspects he has been an excellent signing.
    Ljungberg - Go. Just never got the chance to prove his worth.
    Maloney - Go. The most over rated footballer Celtic has ever produced. No fight, heart or desire and nowhere near as good as he thinks.
    McCourt - Stay. Excellent player to have at your disposal.
    McGinn - Go. Not good enough.
    Ki - Stay/Go. Wouldn't be bothered seeing him leave to be honest, think we can do much better than a pretty passer that isn't willing to grab control of a game.
    Stokes - Stay. Will score plenty for us next season.
    Hooper - Stay. Hopefully a good pre-season and we can get a full season of the form he showed at the start of the year out of him.
    Samaras - Stay/Go. All depends on any prospective bid, don't think he's been as consistently effective off the bench as he was when he first arrived.
    Murphy - Stay/Go. I wouldn't be as bothered as most to see him staying, I think he has a lot of good qualities.
    McGowan - Go. He's a decent player but I think mid-table SPL is his level.
    rasmussen - Go. Carthorse, not good enough.
     
  20. JohnBhoyCfc1

    Joined:
    Jun 17, 2010
    Messages:
    2,538
    Likes Received:
    3
    Location:
    Duke Street
    Fav Celtic Player:
    Gary Hooper + Scott Brown
    Fav Celtic Song:
    Just Cant Get Enough + Hail Hail
    Forster - Go, we can do better.
    Zaluska - Stay as second choice.
    Cervi - Stay, haven't seen much of him.
    Hinkel - Sadfully go, he wants to leave and I rate him so well.
    Wilson - Stay, he's had a great season.
    Cha - Go, not good enough.
    Mulgrew - Stay, is a very versatile player who can be crucial.
    Maj - Tough one, but we need his experience, Stay.
    Loovens - Go, I don't need a reason.
    O'Dea - Go, sorry lad, but you're not good enough.
    Thompson - Stay, he's still to prove himself.
    Izzy - Stay forever.
    Rogne - Solid young centre back, stay.
    Brown - Tough one, one parts telling me stay and the other is saying go. Won't bother what happens to him.
    Commons - Stay
    Forrest - Stay
    Juarez - * give the guy a chance, stay
    Kayal - Stay
    Ledley - Stay
    Ljunberg - Unless we actually use him which I believe we won't, so go.
    Maloney - Stay
    Mccourt - Go
    Mcginn - Go
    Ki - Stay
    Stokes - Stay
    Hooper - Stay
    Samaras - Go and never come back again EVER
    Murphy - Go, not good enough.
    Mcgowan - Go
    Rasmussen - Stay