A CELTIC RELATED THREAD

yes folks here is a celtic related thread ,remember the celtic?the reason we are here

any way,

now that we are in to the "final push" to the title what i am asking is who in your opnion have been the
star men for celtic?

who have been dissapointing?

what game apart from the old firm have you enjoyed watching

what game apart from the old firm is the worst?

how would you rate the team on performances this term 1-10 ..10 being the highest

and what part of the team have been the best ,defence ,midfeild forwards

fav goal?

and finally player of the year "easy question " to finish with

please just write one answer for every question

STAR MAN? brooney

dissapointed in? jvoh

formation? midfeild

most enjoyed match? killie away 1-2 celtic for me showed they can get the head down and get results

worst game to watch? probley st mirren opening game of the season because i expected the bhoys to fly out the traps with the 1st home game and rose burns unfurling the flag

fav goal? mcdonald v killie because it was a winner when we needed it most the 1-2 game

team over all rating:8 because they are top of the table but they fustrate me big time

player of the year so far:scott brown

 

Star Man ? Scott Brown

dissapointed in? Big Jan

formation? 4-4-2

most enjoyed match? Celtic v Dundee Utd most games with us and them have been close and good games this season

worst game to watch? Getting beat at easter road the day of borucs howler

fav goal? Marc Crosas v St Mirren - like the wee man and was great to see him score an absolute rasper

team over all rating: 7 - Been great at times and really poor at other times

player of the year so far: probably Scott Brown

 

1.brooney
2.Samaras
3.Midfield
4.7.0 st mirren
5.0-0 home to huns
6.cosas
7.7 just cause rest of spl are *
8.Scot brown

 

Star Man: Brown - So much energy and dig. Needs to sharpen up the passing at times.

Disappointed - McGeady. Terrible season, picking up now though. There have been a few dissapointments.

Best Match: Villareal at Home.

Worst: Allborg, The Shame at home.

Fav Goal: McDonald vs Man U.

Rating: 8. Doing well to be top considering injuries and crazy form. Need to be more consistent.

 

star man for celtic? Scott Brown

who has been dissapointing? Samaras

what game apart from the old firm have you enjoyed watching ? 7-0 against St. mirren. On the back of some poor performances and we were just excellent that day.

what game apart from the old firm is the worst? The 0-0 game up at ICT. We were just rank rotten that day. No creativity, no end product, nothing.

how would you rate the team on performances this term 1-10 ..10 being the highest ? 7. We've been very poor this season most of the time, but we're top.

and what part of the team have been the best ,defence ,midfeild forwards ? Midfield.

fav goal? Skippy's winner at Ibrox, to get it right up those *.

and finally player of the year ? Broony

 

STAR MAN? Brown

dissapointed in? McGeadys consistancy

formation?

most enjoyed match? Killie game also

worst game to watch? St Mirren 1-0 game. Frustrating

fav goal? MacDonalds second vs Killie. Cool as a breeze

team over all rating: 7- top of the table but I'm still annoyed that we lost that 7 points at xmas

player of the year so far: Broony

 

Star man: Scott Brown

Disappointed in: Jan & Samaras

Best game: The 2-0 win at Tynecastle

Worst game: The 4-2 defeat at Pittidrie

Team rating: 6/10 (We're top but we've been poor in so many games)

Best area of the team: Midfield (When Brown and Crosas play together)

Best goal: The Samaras goal vs Motherwell. Was great team play.

Player of the year so far: Probably Scott Brown overall

 

star men for celtic Scott Brown

who have been dissapointing Big Jan

what game apart from the old firm have you enjoyed watching Hibs 4-2 game

what game apart from the old firm is the worst Inverness 0-0 draw

how would you rate the team on performances this term 1-10 ..10 being the highest 7

and what part of the team have been the best ,defence ,midfeild forwards Midfield

fav goal? I liked Crosas goal

and finally player of the year Scott Brown

 

STAR MAN? brown/caldwell

dissapointed in? Boruc

formation? midfield

most enjoyed match? 7-0 game vs St.Mirren

worst game to watch? St.Mirren - Opening day of the season
fav goal? mcdonald v huns

team over all rating:6 - been poor this season and very inconsistent

player of the year so far:scott brown

 

STAR MAN - Scott Brown

dissapointed in - I thought we'd get more out of Barry Robson this season


most enjoyed match - Motherwell away 4-2 game

worst game to watch - St Mirren in the cup

fav goal - Scott McDonald's against Man Utd


player of the year so far - scott brown <!-- / message --><!-- sig -->

 

Agree with every one of them apart from the best game. For me, the best game was St.Mirren 7-0.

 

Star man: Scott Brown POTY for me

Dissapointed in: Jan Thought he was going to be top draw after pre-season

Excluding Rangers, fave game: Celtic 7 St Mirren 0

Excluding Rangers, least fave game: St Mirren 1 Celtic 0

Fav Goal: Nakamura Vs. St Mirren 3-1 game, out of this world control

Best part of the team: Midfield

Rate the team: 7

POTY: Scott Brown

 

star men for celtic? broon skippy caldwell hinkel

who have been dissapointing?jan

what game apart from the old firm have you enjoyed watching 7-0 st mirren

what game apart from the old firm is the worst? against the dons

how would you rate the team on performances this term 1-10 ..10 being the highest 7

and what part of the team have been the best ,defence ,midfeild forwards. Midfeild, solid

fav goal? Maloney v hearts, mcdonald v killie or crosas v st mirren skippy v man u

POTY; brown caldwell skippy

 

Star Man: Scott Brown

Disapointed in Sammy, big Jan, big Mick, Artur

The Midfeild

The last OF match

Getting put out the Scottish cup by St Mirren

Naylors goal against Dundee United

Overall rating: 7 Just edging it really but not good enough

Player of the year: Scott Brown

 

Star man: Scott Brown

Disappointed in: Vennegoor of Hesselink

Best game: League Cup Final

Worst game: Losing 4-2 at Pittodrie

Team rating: 7/10

Best area of the team: Midfield

Best goal: Scott McDonald v Man United. Incredible feeling, seeing that ball floating into the net.

Player of the year so far: Scott Brown

 

STAR MAN? Caldwell. Only consistent performer

dissapointed in? jvoh / Samaras

formation? eh?

most enjoyed match? 7-0 st mirren. showed what we're capable of when he plays the right midfield

worst game to watch? Either old Trafford or Aalborg away. Both painful in different ways.

fav goal? Skippy at Ibrox

team over all rating: 6 - Best in the league but capable of so much more

player of the year so far - Skippy or Caldwell. Brown is far too inconsistent.

 

do you notice the common denominator here,we more or less all see Celtic the same way ,we are all singing from the same hymn sheet,

and thanks for the way you have posted the answers ,,thanks

 

star man...caldwell
dissapointed in...samaras
formation...442
most enjoyed match....league cup final
worst match...aalborg away
favourite goal...skippy v man utd
team rating...5.5
player of the year so far...caldwell

 

Star Men: Brown and Caldwell for me. Caldwell because of the huge improvement on last season.

Disappointing: Jan for all the injuries and lack of goals. And Sammy because he started so well but his form dipped dramatically after an excellent start.

Most Enjoyable Game: Villarreal at home or last sunday, even thought we drew it was a great game of football.

Worst: St Mirren in the cup, was so frustrating how some just didnt look interested.

Team Rating: 7, havent been at our best much lately but still playing good enought that we already have a trophy in the cabinet and we're top.

Best area of the team: Midfield

Fave Goal: Skippy at Ibrox or Crosas v St Mirren.

Player of the year so far: Brown or Caldwell

:bbpd:

 

STAR MAN?
Scott Brown

Dissapointed in?
Artur Boruc

Formation?
4-4-2
<table class="mainSplTable splTable" style="font-size: smaller;" width="14" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="2" height="17"><tbody><tr><td>
</td> <td class="left">
</td> <td class="left yellow">
</td> <td>
</td> <td>
</td> <td class="green">
</td></tr></tbody></table>Most enjoyed match?
The 1-0 win on the 27th December against Rangers at Ipox

Worst game to watch?
The 2-4 home defeat against Rangers

Fav goal?
Crosas in the 7-0 win against The Buddies. * screamer.

Team over all rating:
7. We are better than the rest but should have had the league sewn up by now.

player of the Year so far:
Scott Brown