Donati-Hit or a Miss?

I know it is too early to judge him completely but so far what are your thoughts on Masimo Donati.

I thought against Parma he was brillaint and against Falkirk he battled extremely hard in on a tight pitch. His passing and awarness is good and he looks good in Midfield when trying to create an opening wiht a cutting pass.

 

so far hes a miss imo. falkirk he wasnt good. and hes only lasted 60min in every game so far
but like you said to early to judge so kinda pointless post imo. i'll not be voting

 

I'm in more favour of hit but i dont think he is quite there yet. of what i have seen i say he has the potential to be a hit. never a miss

 

jesus give the bhoy a chance hes in a new country new team new friends i would give him a few months to settle in get back to match fitness remember hes never been settled at one club as he is always been on the move via loan moves from milan , but i think he will turn good hopefully !

 

I've watched him closely in all the games he's played in for us and the guy oozes class. I think he has adapted superbly to the SPL and our team. Mind Naka didnny settle it straight away to the rough and tumble of the SPL but look at him now? Give the guy a chance to impress.

 

I am not slating him , am just asking peoples opinions bud

 

I know mate, sorry if that comment sounded hostile

It's in our nature as Celtic fans to be critical.

 

Can you not read! So far i am asking people do they think he has been good or bad in the games he has played

 

Lol no bother bud

 

think he looks a class act , when his fitness is better he will do a great job for us

 

Why not. Are you not allowed to see what people think of a players performances in his first few games?

This is why so many arguments start on this site, people nit picking and being critical of other peoples threads and comments...get a grip

 

Its just a bit of fun. No point causin a stir cause someone started a poll, if you think its pointless dont vote. End of.

On Topic: I think he looks like he will be a good player for us, just needs to get more adapted to game and get some more fitness.

 

Well in the games he has played a miss but he has the potential to be a hit.

 

I'm saying miss at the moment but that is being based on 3 games.

I've got an open mind and i don't think we can judge him until Christmas at least as he is learning a new position.

 

Not gonna get on his back just yet, but he has been crap so far. Disappointed me last night, and against Falkirk he was *. Missed 2 good chances and got taken apart by Latapy`s speed twice. Got booked once for hauling him down, and could of seen a second the next time.

 

Think he is a good player. He is a big improvement on JJ or Lenny last season. He passes forward very well. Think he will be a very good player in a few weeks. He looked far better defensively against spartak too.

 

I think he isnt that good atm in competive games, except in pre-season, he looked good. Maybe he was cause of no pressure, or cause he was playing teams not trying as much.

So far he gets tired a bit too much and gives the ball away a bit. I think both problems will be better with time and will look a great player