Kayal or Wanyama

Simple, who is better?

 

Wanyama by a baw hair for me - can play CB too + has the physical advantage, take nothing away from Kayal though

 

Kayal, hes our best player when on form i think.

 

Kayal by a good distance for me. The guy is absolute class and a level above anything in Scotland when on top form. Still getting back to full fitness but some of his moves and passing yesterday were very good. I wish he was given a more advanced role like he seemed to have yesterday. Could be our new Petrov

Wanyama has serious potential and will be playing at the very top of the game in a few years time if he keeps progressing

 

Kayal right now, Wanyama may well be better in 5 years time though.

In my opinion we should play both together in midfield, Wanyama just behind two central midfielders - those being Kayal and either Ledley Brown or Ki depending on the opposition.

 

Didn't we already have a similar poll i.e Who would you rather be sold: Kayal or Wanyama? I will refuse to vote because it's unfair, perhaps at the end of the season I'd be more willing.

 

Didn't see that one. Made this as I was curious to see the general concensus on here. Voted Kayal myself

 

Love Kayal.

 

Why vote we have them both already and when on their games they are some of the best CDM's in Britain (seriously). But like someone said if you were to put each attribute from both players against each other then wanyama would win simply becuase he's younger and can be played in more positions.

 

Wanyama's younger and more versatile.

 

Wanyama

 

Kayal is slightly better than Wanyama, at the moment. Wanyama has the potential to become world class though, as he is a few years younger than Kayal and already has the big EPL clubs, such as Man United, watching him with interest.

 

Kayal is more technically gifted, however Wanyama is more vital to the team because he can play centre mid, holding mid or centre back.


Wanyama just about.

 

Wanyama does not miss half the season injured

 

The injuries are not the fault of Kayal though. They are the fault of the hatchet men in Scottish football who can't keep up with him, or are less talented than him, and then resort to sticking the studs in him. A certain Lee McCulloch springs to mind here.

 

Wanyama for his versatility

 

Both worthy of having their name on the back of my top

 

I actually forgot how good Kayal is due to his long term injury, watch this video. Absolutely amazing footballer.

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sg2Wo9nzBR8"]Kayal vs Hibernian(A) 10-11 - YouTube[/ame]

 

All my thoughts. Kayal is our best player and should be paired with Wanyama in the middle when both are fit. I like both Brown and Ledley but they aren't the same level in my opinion and unfortunately one or both will need to drop out, unless we go with 3 in the middle or they play wide. I don't like Wanyama as a centre half, he is competent there but he is certainly a midfielder.

Kayal is a class act.

 

Kayal and Wanyama should only play with eachother in a 3 man midfield, too similar and combative. Ledley and one of them in a 4-4-2 or all 3 in a 3 man midfield - Which I'd love to see on wednesday with Brown's injury concerns - is the way to go.