James McFadden

2000–2003 Motherwell 63 (26)
2003–2008 Everton 109 (11)
2008– Birmingham City 78 (13)
National team‡
2002– Scotland 45 (15)

() = goals

Not exactly amazing but he has been playing as a wide man alot of them games

 

lets sell a player who plays well 1 in every 7 games (McGeady) and replace him with a player who plays well 1 in every 7 games. McFadden is overrated - he's never really broke through at any point for Birmingham - considering Ferguson gets his game regularly sums it up. No thanks from me

 

He's seen as a striker but has been playing as a winger for Birmingham you never know what your gonna get from Faddy im not sure if its the right move.

 

hes a midfielder, never has been a striker! not even for celtic north

 

Id take him tbh, really like him as a player but this rumour has been done so many times. Id be suprised but happy if we did get him. Just gives us another option out wide because apart from Paddy and maybe Ledley/Juarez if they play there we arent the strongest if Aiden leaves.

 

I would take him, much rather have him in the team than Maloney.

dont think he would cost that much with only a year left on his contract.

 

i'd take him..

people are saying inconsistent like aiden? heres the fact.

aiden mcgeady out £8m

james mcfadden in £3m

i call it, common sense

 

Very good player. Would run riot here. Celtic man to. Surely hes in Eck's plan though? Hes a regular is he not?

 

would do for me wouldn't pay any more than 3mil for him though

 

I reckon McFadden and Hooper could compliment each other well. With either Samaras/Fortune and Rasmussen as backup I'd be really happy with that.

 

Is he not injured a lot also?

 

I'd take him in a heartbeat. Why are people stressing about him not being a goal-machine...Aiden is hardly prolific.

 

Overated IMO but if we do sign him i will give him a chance like everyone else.

Also not really sure where his positon is and he is never fit.

 

If we do sign McFadden, how many strikers will we have? Surely Sammi and Morten would be heading out of the door!!!!

 

HES NOT A STRIKER

 

Well Im sure he said that he would not play for either old firm because he does not want to lose fans at the national arena.

I still would not want him. I just think he would be an expensive waste.

 

would prefer liam lawrence, for less money as well

 

if he did come I would play him right of a 3-man strikeforce so he can cut in on his left foot. Hooper as the main striker and ....bellamy...on the left? :icon_mrgreen:
midfield 3 of kayal, ledley and juarez, fantastic looking team

 

I wouldn't mind seeing him here but tbh I'd be happy playing Fortune and Sammy as our wingers.