Carl Starfelt

As soon as he misplaced a few passes you could feel the nerves emanating from him and bleeding through the team. I think he's a lot better than he showed today but he was terrible.

 

he wasn’t that good..

 

He was atrocious today he was terrible he shouldn't be close to that first team

 

If that's the case and with Jullien getting setbacks....I hope Ange is bringing someone in in January..

He won't last if he can't win his individual battles up against the likes of Nisbet, who isn't even all that physical. It's hardly Dykes on Jullien levels..

It was really hard to watch multiple time's today..

 

He struggles against a guy who plays with his back to goal. He can't play against the Huns bcoz marelos will do him. Welsh is easily the better player.

 

Welsh will get a chance on Wednesday due to suspension, and imo the shirt is his to lose now

 

He's woeful. Lacks presence, doesn't win enough challenges in the air, goes down easy for a CB and has too many blunders in him. Not good enough for the jersey. His problems don't look like ones that can be coached out of him. Always looked like he would give Hibs a chance. Nisbet made him look like an * and it was frankly embarrassing

 

He was really poor.

You know Morelos will be targeting him on the 2nd.

I really hope we've got a center back on the shopping list.

 

Needs to sharpen up and fast. Seen glimpses of a good player but more often than not his lapses in concentration are coming through

 

It's not lapses in Concentration...he's *. As soon as he's backed into he's all over the place. Morelos will thrive playing him bcoz he's getting free kicks for fun. Constantly caught on the wrong side and is an accident waiting to happen and I haven't even started on his passing. Terrible footballer.

 

Lot of hyperbole in here. Could we do better? Of course. And we should be trying to get someone in January to replace him. But he's not * or atrocious, as has been said.

Had a poor first few games. Was getting better and better until the injury. Actually had a couple of fantastic performances as soon as he came back from the injury. Sent off the other night (albeit extremely harshly) and had a shocker of a 20 minute spell today. He's a decent centre half who has had far more good games for us than bad. He'll be a good back up.

A lot of the criticisms are valid. But * me, it's getting quite funny seeing people still peddling the myth that his passing is bad.

 

That one Nisbet skinned him twice was as embarrassing a piece of defending I think I've ever seen.

 

If Welsh or Bitton had performed like that today they would be slaughtered. And rightly so.

 

He made me miss Ambrose ffs. Jullien please come back soon.

 

His positioning is awkward, seems to be wrong side a lot or caught under the ball..

He's lucky we've not been punished more for his errors.

His passing is good but there's a mistake in him every game.

 

I'm sorry but you're starting to make yourself look stupid now. He's *, just admit it. We were playing Hibs today, not Barcelona or Liverpool. He was embarrassed on multiple occasions by bang average opposition. Watching him lose the ball and getting nutmegged by Nisbet while Starfelt was flapping about was comical and embarrassing.

He cannot be trusted against the zombies.

 

The Meg and run past had him flapping and grabbing out even into pen area , but even the attempt to put nesbit off was lame af .

 

Happens to every defender tbf

 

Jullien isn't to far, once he's back I think it'll be him and Carter vickers with Welsh and starfelt fighting it out for a game, not too shabby, he was poor today