Tam Rogic

Im sorry mate but Rogic is done at Celtic.

Cant maintain any kind of fitness and now must be considered third in the attacking mid position behind Christie and Ntcham who both offer far more in terms of work rate, pressing and to the team when compared with TR. On top of that he has hardly featured in pre season.

Its sad to see it but too often now Rogic looks like he is towing a caravan.

 

On top of that, Christie accoriding to Scott Brown is like a dog chasing a bone when trying to win the ball back and presses from the front of the park. That alone to the team is invaluable.

Rogic, in stark contrast, offers nothing defensively.

 

Mental that just a season ago folk were talking about £15m+.

 

Head says punt

Heart says keep forever.

Probably my favourite player in the modern era. That cup final goal will never be forgotten. If he was at all naturally fit he'd be far too good for us.

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

 

During the summer 2018 he was worth it and people would have paid at least 10m for him. But his fitness will put off any suiters.

 

Yeah you maybe right.

Tbh the whole work rate isn't for me, you don't need a team chasing everyone around the park like madmen.

I'd like him to stay, but we'll obviously see how TR is getting on fitness wise and that may well determine his Celtic career.

Stats can be used any which way, for me Rogic has the better head on him for picking passes, remember RC takes setpieces too. Not that I don't like Christie, great work ethic with ability too.

 

I don’t think you can discount work rate, both domestically and against European opposition of similar standing when we play a high tempo pressing game we look a far more dangerous team than when we are deeper and passive.

I would say our defence remains a weak point so the further up the park we can win the ball back the better we can be.

I love Rogic as a player he has ability on the ball that not many in the team come close too including his eye for a killer pass. He is also good for a big goal.

A fit and in form Rogic would be in my team despite what I say above. However, his fitness woes have got worse instead of better. I am starting to think if we got offered a reasonable fee, I would rather see him go and play than be on our treatment table or out of the squad with us all clinging on to hope of the Rogic of old coming back.

 

Agree with all of this. Want him around for the 10 as he's played such a huge part in our successes over those years.

No doubt he's our most naturally talented player and can do things most others can't, but his fitness and performance level is miles off compared to Christie and Ntcham.

 

Well work rate is pretty important in away games especially in europe and Edouard doesnt press with a lot of intensity and tbh I dont think we want him to be doing that because that isnt his game, so by playing TR in the 10 position behind him you are losing the high press.

But quite clearly, Christie just isnt about workrate. His stats are better than big Tams. And big Tams stats have declined markedly over the past three seasons.

You cant keep looking at the situation with sentiment/nostalgia.. i dont think Rogic is that player anymore.

 

I think he'll be gone by the time the window closes. I hope we get a good fee for him.

 

Love Rogic to bits and he has been brilliant for us on his day. Think its time for him to go play in a league that suits him like the Spanish league or Italy. Would be a superstar there.

 

He only got a year left or 2?

 

3

 

I can see why we'd be trying to punt him then..

3 year's and approaching 28. What should be his peak years but with him missing so much time on the park.....we could probably still get a good fee for him now. Maybe China or somewhere like that if he wants to be closer to home and earn a fortune maybe..

 

Rogic passing, ball control and finishing is among the best in the team. No need to punt yet imo, he'll come good in the jam packed season that lies ahead of us.

 

I get the gripes with him and his chocolate bones but he has proved he’s a worthwhile asset. However atm he is a luxury we can afford. When that changes he will be seen as no longer required or unless we find a replacement.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Rogic is one of those players that if he had the fitness then he would’ve been £15/20m+ asset.

Still love him and ideally would prefer if he stayed. Big game player, especially in Europe. That game against Man City comes to mind when he had them on strings the whole night.

 

Few folk on twitter claiming he's asked to leave

 

Be gutted if he goes, what a player

 

Im sorry but for the last few seasons, being one of the higher earners in the squad, he has not been a worthwhile asset.
I dont event think he is competing for a place anymore and thats a sad state of affairs. But as “a luxury we can afford “” why would we want to hang on to a player who is producing less and less for us? Doesnt make sense.