Honest Mistakes Thread 2016/17 onwards.

Is there a proper archive somewhere that shows every red card, goal disallowed and penalty shout this season for and and against us and for and against them? And that has the context eg. The score in the match at the time, what competition it was and the situation in that competition (like what match day and the points each team were on).

 

Maybe the keeper does get to it, doesn't mean the defender pushing into Kyogo making zero attempt at the ball is the problem? Also it doesn't need 4 minutes to check that. IF IT DOES! ADD THAT TIME ON!

 

It's the defender who fouls Kyogo. It's 100% a foul on Kyogo and therefore should've been a penalty. It wasn't just a foul, but it was dangerous play. Kyogo could've easily been injured there.

 

No yellow for the penalty..

Words fail me..

He barely gave us a freekick after the penalty which if we didn't have VAR...he wouldn't have given let that sink in. He had a great view as well..

Went to the monitor and anytime they fell after it was a freekick..

 

How the United player doesn't get a yellow for a deliberate hand ball, when we've had Bernabéi booked for an unknown hand ball behind his back, can only be explained by cheating.

Absolutely zero chance in * you can explain why he doesn't get a second yellow for that handball effort, without telling us he refused to want to send him off.

Specially with VaR now.


Call that out Celtic

Sent from my M2012K11AG using Tapatalk

 

You just said on Sky it wasn't a penalty... make your mind up mate

 

Watched it several times and the Dundee United player makes zero attempt to play the ball and just shoulders then shoved Kyogo into the onrushing keeper.

 

Needs a formal complaint to the SFA after today’s horror show.

 

I was thinking that but it seems the managers are scared to even mention it on the cameras, obviously told if the criticise the decisions publicly they'll receive touchline bans.

 

I don't understand why the utd player wasn't booked then sent off .....no one asking the question!

 

What did people actually expect the SFA to do with VAR once they had their red hands on it? Absolutely no foresight from those who were begging and pleading for its introduction.Dicks.

 

Not a penalty for me. If Hart had done the same thing and we’d been penalised I’d be raging.
Why the Utd. defender wasn’t sent off for our penalty needs explaining. It’s a disgusting decision, again.

 

So even when we get a penalty for a deliberate handball, player isn’t booked, a player who was already on a booking

 

He almost got an assist straight after the penalty with a run and just missed an open goal where he scuffed it with his left peg after that..

If he went off we run riot goal wise..

In what league is that no second yellow. Again, just don't follow the rules in games involving us..

 

I believe they are using the keeper as an excuse to not award the penalty. VAR has probably seen the push by the defender on Kyogo that results in the clash with the keeper and told him not to award the penalty and use the keeper as the reason. * cheats.

 

Was one of the most blatant handballs probably since VAR came in, all the ones * have been booked for and then this guy actually had his arm down and flapped it up to block the ball and never got one.

I thought McMann should have been sent off for the tackle on Abada as well, 99 times out 100 when a guy slides for the ball goes over the ball missing it and into a players shin he gets sent off.

If that was the huns playing them they'd have played the last 20 odd minutes against 9 men for sure.

 

To think Bernabei got a booking for his handball and no booking for the boy today just about sums it up

 

Was coming in here to write those exact words. Disgraceful Bernabei got booked for not knowing anything about what happened, yet the DU player deliberately throws his arm out to stop the ball and has already been booked, gets away without a second yellow.

 

Foster and Stuart Dougal talking over the VAR decisions yesterday.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/av/football/64450420

I've watched these clips a few times and Dougal is always trying to defend the ref and comes up with some stupid excuses.

When reviewing our penalty he admits the decision was a bit subjective. He can see why some people would give that as a penalty.

VAR is only supposed to get involved with clear and obvious errors. If he thinks that could have been a penalty then the ref hasn't made an obvious mistake and there shouldn't have been a review. VAR was wrongly used.

On Jack's tackle he think it was yellow and part of the defence was the tackle was low. It was only his foot and ankle. Only his foot and ankle?

There has been plenty of red cards given for making contact at foot level. Nearly breaking someone's ankle always has always been a red card and never dismissed as only at ankle height.