Discussion in 'Competition Corner' started by Keano88, Apr 23, 2019.
Discuss Songquest: Oldskool in the Competition Corner area at TalkCeltic.net.
The Final 10
Submit any song containing one of the below Elements
@Vertie @Minty @Idioteque @DCI Hed Tastings @borobob @JC Anton @cidermaster @packybhoy @Big els @Vinnie BBQ
So you did deduct 10 points aye, that'll teach me for following the criteria
Just to confirm all scores have been wiped and the scoring system is still in place.
8 will advance, the bottom 2 will be eliminated.
What did you get a deduction for, voting too late?
Refusing to include the song that included love in his votes because he had to re-pick a song due to having love in the title.
Everyone else who had to re-pick (about 5 people) all had no issues at all.
Why didn't everyone that had love, have to re-pick?
Because Big els was the only one who hadn’t re-picked and he isn’t on the forum as regularly as most.
If it was someone I knew would be on the following day then I’d have waited.
At the end of the day nobody else who had to re-pick even mentioned it, they all just voted as usual.
We move on.
There was two songs with love in it, not fair that some changed, some didn't.
Had Fergus McCann moved on, Jim Farry would still be in a job
Life isn’t fair sometimes.
Cidermasters song had Mad in the title.
I’m running the comp, making the playlists, themes, counting votes, updating the league table etc. I can’t be arsed with petty arguments.
You vote or you don’t vote, it doesn’t put me up nor down.
As I said everyone else who had to re-pick got on with it with no issue at all.
I must admit I was very lucky to get through,but once again you are running this Comp brilliantly good pal.
But yes I was very lucky and will take the luck. Maybe our beloved Celtic will have similar luck getting in and through the CL Group Stages next season
I would have still been in the * comp if my love titled song had been accepted that I was thinking of maybe picking.
Oh no you wouldn’t.
Did you have mad or love as well?
Madly you mean?.....doesn't fit the criteria either!
Fair enough, point taken!
I'm continue to be petty, I'll not be voting.
Like I would have accepted Happily instead of Happy or Fearful instead of Fear.
If you want to act like a child as well then fair enough
I had Madly,but as I am actually Mad maybe that is why I got away with it
@Tim-Time 1888 you work with figures, should have just massaged them back in.