Discussion in 'Competition Corner' started by JC Anton, Mar 19, 2019.
Discuss Mafia 45 - Shawshank Redemption in the Competition Corner area at TalkCeltic.net.
potentially a S/K , stood out straight away …. but he discarded S/K
I discarded sk but it wouldn't be unheard of for 2 sks to be offered out or a wildcard who can pick from the discards
Good point about wildcards, that's a strong possibility with all those Mafia discards.
true , just nit picking , day 1 .
I'm not sure what I haven't made clear here. I got a PM from Anton offering me two roles. I chose one and discarded the other.
I cant talk for Obaf because it wasn't a VT role double for me. I have a low level town role.
The goon roles are interesting. Some of those are bound to have been offered two mafia roles.
SK in the film, likelihood of there b
My point was that you said about being offered two roles at the same time, that's the norm, I just didn't get why you mentioned that.
Ignore that first bit in my last post, the bit at the top, draft saved that I didn't need to ask.
I was replying to your initial post asking if mafia roles discarded could have been offered out again. I was merely pointing out that both my role choices came at once.
Wouldn't it be normal to wait and send a pm with both roles rather than two separate PM's? I know that is what you are saying happened, I just don't understand why you made a point of mentioning that your role and discard came in the same pm.
Maybe I'm being pedantic.
I was offered both my options at the same time as usual.
Vote Sean @Seán Mac D been online all day and failed to reply to my friendly post ... that's a bad sign imo so what have you got to say
It's his first game @Tim-Time 1888
I don't have a clue what your post meant to be honest or what the aim of the game is, so I thought it was best to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak up and remove all doubt.
What can I say, I'm a *
Welcome to the game
I just said from your discard that its good when someone, You, picks town rather than mafia/scum that's all.
you said it, not me
His discard shows nothing other than he discarded Town and has claimed Town.
Could this game have another Mafia faction?
We've had a couple of games where there's been more than one mafia faction.....Breaking Bad we had Heisenberg and the Cartel.
We had another game where there was Italian Mafia and Irish Mafia
@Tim-Time 1888 doing his usual apple shaking with the newbie
And as you know it does work
I see you just had the one faction to choose from, so at least we know what side you are on.
Ooh, does it
I can imagine the shock you are all in with me turning down mafia hardcunt But i'v been mafia or other scum in the last 3 or 4 games i think and as much as i clearly enjoy it I needed a change of scenery as it was getting tedious haha
Anyway without stating the obvious there are an unreal amount of Mafia discards and no Alien ones, for me i reckon there are two mafia factions, guards and prisoners maybe? Haven't watched the film in years cant remember if there was a bad group of prisoners or another group that could be bad with the guards but there was 8 mafia roles on discards thats an awful lot considering others will of taken mafia.
Ah, you're still shaking the tree....carry on