Dumfermline 0-4 Celtic

[Murphy7]

Originally Posted by Dalkeith Davie

I agree but Donald McVicar stated last week that if any player raises there hand to an official it is an automatic red card, ie inconsistant refereeing.

Inconsistant refereeing is just part of football. How many times have you heard a commentator say, "I've seen those given" on penalty appeals. It's part of the reason why football is the game we all love.

[Dalkeith Davie]

Originally Posted by Murphy7

Inconsistant refereeing is just part of football. How many times have you heard a commentator say, "I've seen those given" on penalty appeals. It's part of the reason why football is the game we all love.

Yes i know it is part of the game we love but since the subject is in focus because of last week i thought you would have included it in your report.I wonder if it will be reported in the papers tommorrow.

[Murphy7]

Originally Posted by Dalkeith Davie

Yes i know it is part of the game we love but since the subject is in focus because of last week i thought you would have included it in your report.I wonder if it will be reported in the papers tommorrow.

I seriously doubt it will get much press coverage. Time will tell though.

[Dalkeith Davie]

Originally Posted by Murphy7

I seriously doubt it will get much press coverage. Time will tell though.

Will wait and see an may continue this debate later.

[Murphy7]

Originally Posted by Dalkeith Davie

Will wait and see an may continue this debate later.

I wonder what other people think on the subject.

[Dalkeith Davie]

Originally Posted by Murphy7

I wonder what other people think on the subject.

Should start a new thread tommorrow and we will see.

[Murphy7]

Originally Posted by Dalkeith Davie

Should start a new thread tommorrow and we will see.

That's a good idea. We should include a poll as well.

[ExPatBhoy]

Originally Posted by Murphy7

No.

imo, officials should do all they can to keep 22 players on the pitch. As sendings off ruin the game and deprive the paying public of a competitive game of football.

Good effort Murphy - enjoy the new job

[Murphy7]

Originally Posted by ExPatBhoy

Good effort Murphy - enjoy the new job

Cheers, although I don't see it at as a job.

[ExPatBhoy]

Originally Posted by Murphy7

Cheers, although I don't see it at as a job.

OK - labour of love

[Mac]

good, good :)
Bravo Murphy!

[Torq]

Originally Posted by Murphy7

I'm open to both positive and negative feedback. I like people to say it as it is.

Cheers Mutphy ! Great article.
I always said that you're the smart one here !
You'll go far in life boy I'm telling you this

[kowal22]

Good job Murphy. My m8 is a sport journalist in Gazeta Wyborcza (most popular daily newspaper in Poland), I know it's a difficult job.

[Yorkshire Tim]

This report seems fine to me.

Do I still have to write out reports if there's going to be one straight away?

Take it you wrote all this out yourself Murphy?

Take it I'm sacked then?

[HH]

Originally Posted by yorkshire tim

This report seems fine to me.

Glad of your approval YT.

Originally Posted by yorkshire tim

Do I still have to write out reports if there's going to be one straight away?

If yer no fast yer last, as they say.

Originally Posted by yorkshire tim

Take it you wrote all this out yourself Murphy?

Oh come on YT, your envy is seeping out onto the pages.

Originally Posted by yorkshire tim

Take it I'm sacked then?

If you want. OR. You can always give us your version. Would be nice to read other reports. However a wee bit of controvery wouldnt go amis.

ie. " Celtic cruised to a 4-0 victory at EEP today, amazingly with that fat fuck Hartson in the team. Although slower than a week in the jail, Jabba managed to latch onto a gift from the Pars GK Hallibut, who fluffed a clearance straight to the Welsh Heffer." etc etc