gary caldwell our best defender!

[jpr21]

Originally Posted by Hammer

No i'm not he is one of the best passers of a football for a centre half in the whole of Britain, fact.

i tell you one thing, this man knows his stuff. i have noticed a complete change in caldwells game and i think WGS can take credit. a few months back, with the ball at feet, caldwell used to try and play it on the floor to our centre mids with their backs to goal. know, as soon as he gets the ball, he either looks to play it to the full back, like any good centreback does, or, he takes a touch and pings lofted balls to the attackers, or the wingers, EVERYTIME now. he is a brilliant long passer of the ball, one of the best ball playing centre backs around. watch for this in the next game, he always lofts balls to palyers perfectly.

[jpr21]

Originally Posted by Hammer

No chance, he'd have hit the corner flag if he tried that.

just like he hit the corner flag when he lofted the ball to scott mcdonalds head perfectly in the old firm game in the last minute when JVOH scored? everytime he gets the ball, head up, nad a beautifully pinged lofted pass to an attacker or winger. actually watch the games mate , no point slamming him if it aint true pal.
best player on the park against hibs today

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by hairytoes

Are you really slagging off Caldwell in one post & calling for Tommy Graveson to replace either Hartley or Robson in another?

If you are (no offense) your a mad mental utter nutter from crazy land, with a masters in stupid ideas!

Caldwell has been great recently, look at Graveson in the EPL & Miller too!

Ha

Yeah as ive already said, caldwell has bn good recently but think hes generally not Celtic class


and yeh i was a tommy g fan.

But hey, it wud b a borin world if we all thought the same.

[rd-67-]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

Ha

Yeah as ive already said, caldwell has bn good recently but think hes generally not Celtic class


and yeh i was a tommy g fan.

But hey, it wud b a borin world if we all thought the same.

do you not think he could grow into celtic class?

i dont agree with this celtic class pish. players can fluctuate in and out of the celtic class bracket. the way hes played the past 2 months proves he can be celtic class. and whos to say he wont continue and improve?

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by tim park

odea v cauldwell,, are u having a laugh,,,,,,although a promising young star thats what he is A YOUNGSTER

AN UN PROVEN YOUNGSTAR. with out being cheeky m8,, but your take on cauldwell is shite with a captail S

Fair enough, but I think Caldwell is Shite with a capital S and one good month wont change my mind.

McGeady is a youngster as well, as is Caddis, guys who've been given a chance. How can O'Dea prove himself sitting on the bench? Caldwell has had a good month but has had a lot of bad months as well.

Every time O'Dea has been given a chance in the middle he's been outstanding, including in the san siro when he was man of the match.

[Martin]

Caldwell has been excellent of late and after the pelters he's had it has taken real character to turn his game around. Well down Caldwell.

However he still has a long way to go before he has played more good games than bad games.

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by rd-67-

do you not think he could grow into celtic class?

i dont agree with this celtic class pish. players can fluctuate in and out of the celtic class bracket. the way hes played the past 2 months proves he can be celtic class. and whos to say he wont continue and improve?

Maybe but its not like he's 18, and he's been given a long extended run in the team already, 2 seasons basically.

As long as he pulls on the jersey he'll get my backing like evry1 else, but nope, not for me. He gives me palpatations every time hes got the ball at his feet. I really dont see this great range of passing at all, he has a habit of launching the ball aimlessly into the channel and then pointing at McDonald as if he was supposed to grow extra long legs and get there.

[rd-67-]

hes been better than mcmanus this season. people bring him up for his mistake against barca but what about micks against shakhtar and aberdeen?

[clagan24]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

caldwell has bn good recently but think hes generally not Celtic class

here we go again

[Hammer]

Originally Posted by jpr21

just like he hit the corner flag when he lofted the ball to scott mcdonalds head perfectly in the old firm game in the last minute when JVOH scored? everytime he gets the ball, head up, nad a beautifully pinged lofted pass to an attacker or winger. actually watch the games mate , no point slamming him if it aint true pal.
best player on the park against hibs today

Tongue in cheek bud, i'm one of his most vocal fans

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by clagan24

here we go again

wtf does that mean?

Its simple, I expect defenders better than him to play for celtic, its just a quicker way of saying it.

[rd-67-]

lol what does celtic class mean? good enough to play a game of football in the hoops and be a success? or please the fans? hes clearly good enough because he is the best defender in the best defence in the SPL

[clagan24]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

wtf does that mean?

Its simple, I expect defenders better than him to play for celtic, its just a quicker way of saying it.

fed up of hearing about celtic class mate. no offence, its just that anytime someone mentions "celtic class" it always starts another debate about what is "celtic class"............

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by rd-67-

lol what does celtic class mean? good enough to play a game of football in the hoops and be a success? or please the fans? hes clearly good enough because he is the best defender in the best defence in the SPL

A level above a joe normal bread n butter defender, good enough to play for average SPL sides, which i dont think he is, why does the phrase Celtic-class cause so much offence to people?

[Dempsey]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

He was at Centre half when he passed the ball to Ronaldinho and he was at centre half when he had the mother of all nightmares in Benfica, so i dont think u can put his errors down to being out of position.

Do you remember in all the league matches (about 14 of them) before that game? No one mistake from him or Mick but one howler of a game and he's condemned for the rest of his career?

Well done Gary, keep it up!