gary caldwell our best defender!

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by Ham&Jam

He is a very good player! He is in the Scotland squad too. Celtic fans got on his back when he was played out of position and had two or three howling mistakes.

Give the guy a break, he was outstanding today!

He was at Centre half when he passed the ball to Ronaldinho and he was at centre half when he had the mother of all nightmares in Benfica, so i dont think u can put his errors down to being out of position.

I dont think the guys a good passer at all and he just looks so awkward and clumsy on the ball.

Cant fault him for effort, but as Kenny Miller proved, effort doesnt make u a good player.

[gazbhoy88]

dont doubt he tries his best and he's been doing well lately but he still makes basic mistakes and its not easy to forget the nighttmare he had away to benfica!

Hard worker but nt quite celtic class!

HAIL! HAIL!

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by tim park

you say long term ,how do u know that,,can u see the future ,how do u know his performances are gong to dip or even they might get better still,,

by saying not long term,,,,uve comdemned him before hes played ,,wait till next season and when uve saw him play then mabye u would get a more clear answer


im no diggin at u m8,it sounds as if i am,,, but surely the future will look after its self

Know ur not digging and happy to debate the point

I dont want to wait until he makes another mistake before hes replaced. I said pre-barca he was an accident waiting to happen and so it proved. Gave the ball to ronaldinho for the 2nd goal and was made to look like a doughball by messi for the 3rd.

Look across the city at Cuellar in comparison.

We need someone like that to partner Mick.

[Ham&Jam]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

He was at Centre half when he passed the ball to Ronaldinho and he was at centre half when he had the mother of all nightmares in Benfica, so i dont think u can put his errors down to being out of position.

I dont think the guys a good passer at all and he just looks so awkward and clumsy on the ball.

Cant fault him for effort, but as Kenny Miller proved, effort doesnt make u a good player.

You hate the guy - fair enough! No argument then.

[tim park]

Originally Posted by gazbhoy88

dont doubt he tries his best and he's been doing well lately but he still makes basic mistakes and its not easy to forget the nighttmare he had away to benfica!

Hard worker but nt quite celtic class!

HAIL! HAIL!

that was nearly 2 seasons ago m8,, ,,if u cant see the good as well as bad in folk ,not just in football but life as well

cauldedwell and the team progressed to the last 16,,so it wasent that cosly plus do u forget about his pass to naka midweek hungame ,,,or his pass to skippy for vennegoor to score last min

these moments should be the unforgetable moments not the benfica one

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by Ham&Jam

You hate the guy - fair enough! No argument then.

erm... no

Im sure he's a nice guy and good fun at barbecues etc, so wouldn't quite say i hate him.

Just wouldn't put him my footie team

[tim park]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

erm... no

Im sure he's a nice guy and good fun at barbecues etc, so wouldn't quite say i hate him.

Just wouldn't put him my footie team

replacements ?

[Ham&Jam]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

erm... no

Im sure he's a nice guy and good fun at barbecues etc, so wouldn't quite say i hate him.

Just wouldn't put him my footie team

You are Alex Ferguson aren't you? You cheeky git Fergie - fuckin knew it!

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by tim park

replacements ?

From the current squad, I would like to see O'Dea given a run in the middle. He was magnificent in the san siro and has impressed any time he's played there.

Think we really need to bring someone in though and hopefully the scouts are already out there looking.

[Rossenspeil]

Originally Posted by Ham&Jam

You are Alex Ferguson aren't you? You cheeky git Fergie - fuckin knew it!

Vewy Vewy pwoud

[Ham&Jam]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

Vewy Vewy pwoud

Still a Caldwell fan though. He is a winner

I had Man City to win on my coupon. That was a loser - big time WTF?

[tim park]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

From the current squad, I would like to see O'Dea given a run in the middle. He was magnificent in the san siro and has impressed any time he's played there.

Think we really need to bring someone in though and hopefully the scouts are already out there looking.

odea v cauldwell,, are u having a laugh,,,,,,although a promising young star thats what he is A YOUNGSTER

AN UN PROVEN YOUNGSTAR. with out being cheeky m8,, but your take on cauldwell is shite with a captail S

[hairytoes]

Originally Posted by Rossenspeil

He was at Centre half when he passed the ball to Ronaldinho and he was at centre half when he had the mother of all nightmares in Benfica, so i dont think u can put his errors down to being out of position.

I dont think the guys a good passer at all and he just looks so awkward and clumsy on the ball.

Cant fault him for effort, but as Kenny Miller proved, effort doesnt make u a good player.

Are you really slagging off Caldwell in one post & calling for Tommy Graveson to replace either Hartley or Robson in another?

If you are (no offense) your a mad mental utter nutter from crazy land, with a masters in stupid ideas!

Caldwell has been great recently, look at Graveson in the EPL & Miller too!

[chunkystriker]

Amazing what happens with a wee bit of confidence and not half as many groans and moans everytime the guy touches the ball eh?Ilike him as a player but dont get me wrong,i'd still like to see his recent form on a regular and consistant basis!

[jpr21]

im really pleased with th e way cladwell has improved and matured as a player. i didnt realise he was still young, 24 i think. in thought he was in his 30's for some reason. he looks like he could improve further, he deserves credit now, and i believe he should stay ...